Rather than pick apart every post on this, I would just like to say what’s been on my mind over the last few days.
To all of you who seemingly knee-jerk reacted that Pittsburgh needed a “JACK”/variety hits station, only some of you actually took the time to dig deeper into what that type format is actually about. The numb-skulls who now post that the format sucks are the narrow-minded ones. Let me do this. I’ll list a sample hour of “BOB” and a sample hour of “JACK,’ and YOU tell ME which is which. I’m not going to give an answer. Here’s station #1:
FOREIGNER/ Head Games
NELSON/ (Can’ Live Without Your) Love and Affection
CREEDENCE CLEARWATER REVIVAL/ Who’ll Stop The Rain
MEAT LOAF/ Two Out Of Three Ain’t Bad
WAR/ The Cisco Kid
LIFEHOUSE/ Hanging By A Moment
PHIL COLLINS/ Something Happened On The Way To Heaven
TOM PETTY/ I Won’t Back Down
JANET JACKSON/ When I Think Of You
ELTON JOHN/ Your Song
SANTANA/ Why Don’t You & I
Okay, now compare that to……….
THE CURE/ Friday I’m In Love
JOHN COUGAR MELLENCAMP/ Crumblin’ Down
BERLIN/ Metro
T REX/ (Bang A Gong) Get It On
HOOBASTANK/ The Reason
THE ROLLING STONES/ Beast Of Burden (…I’ll never leave your pizza burnin’)
TALK TALK/ Talk Talk
FOREIGNER/ Double Vision
TRACY CHAPMAN/ Fast Car
SKID ROW/ I Remember You
GREEN DAY/ Boulevard Of Broken Dreams
Okay, here’s your assignment. Which sample comes from JACK, and which one comes from BOB? If you heard these songs played back to back without liners, positioners, etc., how would you rate the selection? No one can really compare BOB and/or JACK to anything else because these are 2 formats that are precedent-setting. NO ONE has ever developed anything like this before. If you look at BOB stations and JACK, the biggest difference is that BOB is LIVE & LOCAL. Jack has 1 voice-tracked male, period. I know that for a fact. This little assignment will weed out the REAL radio people and those who THINK they know radio……for reasons the REAL radio will only know.
I wanted to take all of the previous posts and paste them onto a separate page and then give my opinion, but after looking at so many asinine posts (not all of them) where I could see prejudice through the words and people name-calling and acting like juveniles, I thought better and just posted my thoughts alone. My feeling is this: this WILL work in Pittsburgh because people are tired of the same old stuff…..look at the Arbs. How many stations have lost vs. those who have gained over a period of time, and even those who seem stagnant? I can’t tell you how many times listeners call in and give me the standard “you seem to play the same stuff” or “you seem to play the same stuff as (your competition)“ line. From a ratings standpoint, this format has unlimited growth potential. If it’s sold, promoted, & marketed heavily and successfully, it can go nowhere but up. If you believe in the product and do everything within yourself to promote and market it, then it’ll grow and prosper. And I really DO have an argument for those nay-sayers out there, and as The Rock says “bring it on!”
Am I being pissy? HELL, YEAH! It’s those of you who cried sooooooo long for this format but yet are wrongly critical when it DOES happen. I can just tell the un-educated from the educated just by reading what’s written. Those who put it down already are prejudiced against it in 1 form or another, and/or are so jealous that someone other than CC or Infinity actually had the stones to go out and DO IT! I’ve heard for TOO long on how Pittsburgh & this region was so provincial and too deep in their roots to actually try something new. Well, now someone has & I applaud them wholeheartedly.
And before you rip off a “….well it’s not working in New York City” reply, think this over. Infinity pulled the plug on a Heritage Oldies station AND let go a legendary disc jockey, Cousin Brucie. I don’t think ANYONE could recover from all of the negative national press that it got. As for why WCBS let Cousin go, that I don’t know. He could’ve been let go for a number of reasons, whether it was his decision or Infinity’s. But for anyone to overcome that is indeed an uphill battle.
Well, I’ve said my piece. By the way, have you figured out the assignment yet?
To all of you who seemingly knee-jerk reacted that Pittsburgh needed a “JACK”/variety hits station, only some of you actually took the time to dig deeper into what that type format is actually about. The numb-skulls who now post that the format sucks are the narrow-minded ones. Let me do this. I’ll list a sample hour of “BOB” and a sample hour of “JACK,’ and YOU tell ME which is which. I’m not going to give an answer. Here’s station #1:
FOREIGNER/ Head Games
NELSON/ (Can’ Live Without Your) Love and Affection
CREEDENCE CLEARWATER REVIVAL/ Who’ll Stop The Rain
MEAT LOAF/ Two Out Of Three Ain’t Bad
WAR/ The Cisco Kid
LIFEHOUSE/ Hanging By A Moment
PHIL COLLINS/ Something Happened On The Way To Heaven
TOM PETTY/ I Won’t Back Down
JANET JACKSON/ When I Think Of You
ELTON JOHN/ Your Song
SANTANA/ Why Don’t You & I
Okay, now compare that to……….
THE CURE/ Friday I’m In Love
JOHN COUGAR MELLENCAMP/ Crumblin’ Down
BERLIN/ Metro
T REX/ (Bang A Gong) Get It On
HOOBASTANK/ The Reason
THE ROLLING STONES/ Beast Of Burden (…I’ll never leave your pizza burnin’)
TALK TALK/ Talk Talk
FOREIGNER/ Double Vision
TRACY CHAPMAN/ Fast Car
SKID ROW/ I Remember You
GREEN DAY/ Boulevard Of Broken Dreams
Okay, here’s your assignment. Which sample comes from JACK, and which one comes from BOB? If you heard these songs played back to back without liners, positioners, etc., how would you rate the selection? No one can really compare BOB and/or JACK to anything else because these are 2 formats that are precedent-setting. NO ONE has ever developed anything like this before. If you look at BOB stations and JACK, the biggest difference is that BOB is LIVE & LOCAL. Jack has 1 voice-tracked male, period. I know that for a fact. This little assignment will weed out the REAL radio people and those who THINK they know radio……for reasons the REAL radio will only know.
I wanted to take all of the previous posts and paste them onto a separate page and then give my opinion, but after looking at so many asinine posts (not all of them) where I could see prejudice through the words and people name-calling and acting like juveniles, I thought better and just posted my thoughts alone. My feeling is this: this WILL work in Pittsburgh because people are tired of the same old stuff…..look at the Arbs. How many stations have lost vs. those who have gained over a period of time, and even those who seem stagnant? I can’t tell you how many times listeners call in and give me the standard “you seem to play the same stuff” or “you seem to play the same stuff as (your competition)“ line. From a ratings standpoint, this format has unlimited growth potential. If it’s sold, promoted, & marketed heavily and successfully, it can go nowhere but up. If you believe in the product and do everything within yourself to promote and market it, then it’ll grow and prosper. And I really DO have an argument for those nay-sayers out there, and as The Rock says “bring it on!”
Am I being pissy? HELL, YEAH! It’s those of you who cried sooooooo long for this format but yet are wrongly critical when it DOES happen. I can just tell the un-educated from the educated just by reading what’s written. Those who put it down already are prejudiced against it in 1 form or another, and/or are so jealous that someone other than CC or Infinity actually had the stones to go out and DO IT! I’ve heard for TOO long on how Pittsburgh & this region was so provincial and too deep in their roots to actually try something new. Well, now someone has & I applaud them wholeheartedly.
And before you rip off a “….well it’s not working in New York City” reply, think this over. Infinity pulled the plug on a Heritage Oldies station AND let go a legendary disc jockey, Cousin Brucie. I don’t think ANYONE could recover from all of the negative national press that it got. As for why WCBS let Cousin go, that I don’t know. He could’ve been let go for a number of reasons, whether it was his decision or Infinity’s. But for anyone to overcome that is indeed an uphill battle.
Well, I’ve said my piece. By the way, have you figured out the assignment yet?