• Get involved.
    We want your input!
    Apply for Membership and join the conversations about everything related to broadcasting.

    After we receive your registration, a moderator will review it. After your registration is approved, you will be permitted to post.
    If you use a disposable or false email address, your registration will be rejected.

    After your membership is approved, please take a minute to tell us a little bit about yourself.
    https://www.radiodiscussions.com/forums/introduce-yourself.1088/

    Thanks in advance and have fun!
    RadioDiscussions Administrators

Hope For Haiti - Radio?

I hope that, as I have been doing this evening (Jan. 22 2010), you also have been able to watch the Hope for Haiti benefit concert on most of the commercial TV networks, as well as PBS, CBC, HBO and a few other cable channels. Incredibly moving, just the right thing to help mobilize support for relief and ongoing sustainability to the nation of Haiti, and a chance to witness American broadcasting and musicians at their best. I hope they raise many millions that will help the suffering people of Haiti.

I scanned my kitchen FM radio around the start of the TV broadcast (delayed for Pacific time zone), but didn't find any stations at all doing a simulcast. Wondering if there was not a radio-friendly version of the telecast being offered thru the usual distribution systems, or if no station in Seattle took it. Or if someone ran it at 5pm PT from the live Eastern time zone broadcast. It really would have been adequate to just run the audio, without audio commentary added in, since the support pitches mentioned the phone number and website for contributions.

I PD'd at a medium market NPR station during 9-11, and regretted that we had no access thru the public radio satellite system to get a feed of the similar post-9-11 concert, and so stuck with a mix of NPR and BBC coverage and local call-ins during the national concert on Sept. 15,, 2001. But I recall many of the area commercial stations were able to simulcast it, and did.

Other thoughs: if the only thing your station's listeners hear about Haiti are the sick Tourette's-flavored ramblings of Limbaugh or Pat Robertson or their imitators, I hope your conscience gets the better of you and you will do something postive on the air to assist in the fundraising efforts. Without even weighing the public relations benefit. Just do it.

Other radio thoughts: What marvelous music performances tonight. The "covers" of major songs by other major artists were revelations to hear. The tone and substance of the lyrics touched my soul in ways no news coverage or commentary could ever match.

For my taste, it would also be a real class act to hear just one radio station in Seattle offer a music format with the depth and restraint of the performances we heard tonight on TV. A medium and downtempo format of adult rock and related genres. And enough variety to be able to occasionally add in some real spice, like the Haitian performances, for example. No screaming promos. Sounds like an NPR-AAA type of format, but I think a commercial operator with a better than average sense of taste and a talented sales force could find a new audience that's not being addressed with the current music formats. The content, and the presentation style, designed for smart people who don't like to be yelled at. Something on the order or WXRT Chicago and what I remember KINK Portland sounding like last year are in the ballpark of what I'm suggesting.

On a different level, it was an interesting chance to compare any differences between outlets on their HD video and audio. The only differences I noticed, via Comcast cable, were a louder, processed (but not unpleasant) sound on channel 11/111, and a slightly less clear and vibrant picture quality on KCTS 9/109 than the rest. Glad, for reasons of the content and effort, to see nearly every local TV outlet provide a Friday night for the Haiti relief fundraiser.

Please share your impressions of the special broadcast tonight. Let's presume we'll all donate what we can, and that information can remain private and between you, your maker, and your credit card company.

Did anyone else find tonight's telecast a powerful broadcast expereince? And can we get some more buy-in from the powers that be at radio stations in our town, commmerical AND non-comms, too?

GL
 
We donated $250.

It just blows my mind....111,000 people dead. And the counting is STILL far from over....

I noticed the Fox News Channel was strangely absent from all other networks in this telethon. Even Food Network and the Golf Channel simulcasted this telethon. Probably would be bad for ratings to show they had a heart........

Radio wise, a lot more could have been done because it was that important...I noticed very little myself...
 
I didn't check the radio, but I noticed that the OTA "religious" stations weren't carrying the telethon. Specifically, KTBW-20 (TBN), KDWK-42 (Daystar) and to a lesser extent, KWPX-33 (ION). KDWK only has one "service" in their digital channel but KTBW has 5 overtly religious ones and KWPX has 4 services, three of which you could have run the telethon on (ION, ION Life and Worship Network). I am unable to pull in the 3ABN LP station where I live. Making a broad generalization, it seems as if the religious broadcasters are unwilling to actually pitch in and help others in times of need. Perhaps they were not offered the opportunity of carrying the telethon, or perhaps they took the attitude of Pat Robertson, that the Haiti Earthquake was "all their fault".

I also noticed that My Network was not carrying the telethon.

Val
 
People who watch "religious" broadcasters, as you put it, donate to charity all year long. They don't wait until some "hollywood" entertainer asks them to. They already support missionary and humanitarian causes as a lifestyle choice.
 
Goldilocks94941 said:
I scanned my kitchen FM radio around the start of the TV broadcast (delayed for Pacific time zone), but didn't find any stations at all doing a simulcast. Wondering if there was not a radio-friendly version of the telecast being offered thru the usual distribution systems, or if no station in Seattle took it.

There was a radio version available free from Westwood One. I also don't know if any station ran it @ 5pm but I suspect no one did.

Goldilocks94941 said:
Other radio thoughts: What marvelous music performances tonight. The "covers" of major songs by other major artists were revelations to hear. The tone and substance of the lyrics touched my soul in ways no news coverage or commentary could ever match.

For my taste, it would also be a real class act to hear just one radio station in Seattle offer a music format with the depth and restraint of the performances we heard tonight on TV. A medium and downtempo format of adult rock and related genres. And enough variety to be able to occasionally add in some real spice, like the Haitian performances, for example. No screaming promos. Sounds like an NPR-AAA type of format, but I think a commercial operator with a better than average sense of taste and a talented sales force could find a new audience that's not being addressed with the current music formats.

That format may be fine for a two hour special event but there's not enough listenership to make it a profitable format. You know the rules - when in doubt, follow the money.
 
Bongwater said:
I noticed the Fox News Channel was strangely absent from all other networks in this telethon. Even Food Network and the Golf Channel simulcasted this telethon. Probably would be bad for ratings to show they had a heart........

MSNBC didn't air it either. It also aired on channels like Discovery Health Channel but not on regular discovery...seems like there was no one rhyme or reason for a network on cable carring it except to air it.

re: religous broadcasters, as another poster pointed out most Chrisitans are supporting Haiti releif effort and in fact a lot of them have been doing so for many years pre earth quake. Alot of Christian Radio is going to get together with Compassion on Feb1st for a big awareness-fundraiser.
 
Gotta figure they're uncomfortable having "Secular" entertainers on their airwaves. I used to work for some of these kinds of stations years ago (including Crista) who considered anyone who wasn't part of their subculture to be a "nonChristian." Imagine, letting someone like Stevie Wonder sing over a consecrated transmitter! What's next? A one-world government??!!

I'm not exaggerating at this portrayal, and expect that's exactly why they wouldn't get on board with the rest of the media to participate.
Can't say what the excuse is for none of the commercial radio stations in Seattle to have participated, however. There are others who looks at this board who can do that.

Now if the fundamentalists would only stick to that 'Be ye seperate from the World" philosophy in their political activites, (and the mean ol' government would come down on them when they violate the requirements to be non-partisan and non-political to keep their 501(c)3 non-profit tax-exempt status), then the rest of us could live our lives without constantly having to respond to their antics as they try to "win the world" to all be just like them, and to support what they believe to be in their economic interest.

But I digress. . .
 
I don't know if the Westwood One and MTV feeds were anything other than just the audio portion of the broadcast, but if that was the case, it was not a "radio-friendly" event as far as providing basic information. Watching the telecast, there were no graphics or audio to identify either the celebrities or the musical performers. Only Anderson Cooper and Wyclef Jean identified themselves. The rest of the time, the audience was left to guess the identities of many of those who appeared. I only heard one occasion during the telecast where the telephone number for donations/pledges was audibly given. These were the same issues that plagued the post-9/11 event. It was indeed a noble effort, but if radio was to be part of the equation, it fell short.
 
Goldilocks94941 said:
Gotta figure they're uncomfortable having "Secular" entertainers on their airwaves. I used to work for some of these kinds of stations years ago (including Crista) who considered anyone who wasn't part of their subculture to be a "nonChristian." Imagine, letting someone like Stevie Wonder sing over a consecrated transmitter! What's next? A one-world government??!!

I'm not exaggerating at this portrayal, and expect that's exactly why they wouldn't get on board with the rest of the media to participate.
Can't say what the excuse is for none of the commercial radio stations in Seattle to have participated, however. There are others who looks at this board who can do that.

Now if the fundamentalists would only stick to that 'Be ye seperate from the World" philosophy in their political activites, (and the mean ol' government would come down on them when they violate the requirements to be non-partisan and non-political to keep their 501(c)3 non-profit tax-exempt status), then the rest of us could live our lives without constantly having to respond to their antics as they try to "win the world" to all be just like them, and to support what they believe to be in their economic interest.

But I digress. . .

Bringing it back to the Haiti situation, I would definitely check out an organization before giving money for Haiti. I once worked for a major religious broadcaster. Sometimes all the money collected for a "cause" didn't actually go to that cause. They always had fine print that if they collected more than the "budgeted amount" for the cause, then the money would go toward general ministry expenses. And, sadly, the budgeted amount was always far less than they collected.
 
From the other side of the country:

I had to throw in my two cents after reading about this discussion on today's T-R-I. No station in our market aired the concert either. (My station tried to access the broadcast, but we do not have any ties to Westwood One or Premiere, so we could not downlink it). I listened to some of Westwood One broadcast on Sirius XM, and they did provide a different type of feed for the radio broadcast (not just a TV simulcast). There were audio fillers produced and they constantly gave out the phone number. It really was a great effort and it was sad to see that yes, almost every TV channel had it on, but radio did not follow suit...even though the radio effort was just as good as the TV effort.
 
Altho' I would have liked to have know who a few of the performers were in the broadcast, I actually think it was classy to not have an "emcee" or a type of "play by play," and just let the words and lyrics speak at that much more clearly for themselves. The network "bugs" on the screen where enough promotion during an event that was mercifully devoid of self-congratulation.

A radio version only really needed to give the phone number and email addresses (I did hear them given out by speakers, but didn't keep track of how often) for the simulcast to work.
 
Status
This thread has been closed due to inactivity. You can create a new thread to discuss this topic.


Back
Top Bottom