• Get involved.
    We want your input!
    Apply for Membership and join the conversations about everything related to broadcasting.

    After we receive your registration, a moderator will review it. After your registration is approved, you will be permitted to post.
    If you use a disposable or false email address, your registration will be rejected.

    After your membership is approved, please take a minute to tell us a little bit about yourself.
    https://www.radiodiscussions.com/forums/introduce-yourself.1088/

    Thanks in advance and have fun!
    RadioDiscussions Administrators

Jason Aldean's "Try That in a Small Town" banned by CMT

Status
Not open for further replies.
Looking at the Mediabase chart today, the song is still growing in airplay on country radio. Remember this entire controversy is about the video. The song was released in May, and the video came out last week. Only CMT has said it won't air the video due to complaints from the public. There isn't another country music cable TV channel anymore. Great American Country was sold some time ago.
Vevo and iHeart have 24/7 country video channels on Xumo, Pluto, Sling Free and similar services. Again, who's watching? For what it's worth, all three contemporary country stations up here are on the Aldean song and have been for the past couple of weeks. This is a liberal area of Vermont but that's not keeping "Try That" off the playlists. Every time it's played on one of those stations, it's preceded with hype about it being "another sizzling new single,"
 
Is this going to be like “Baby it’s cold outside” where one of hundreds of media outlets drop it, in that case it was a San Francisco radio station. So people overreact and we get the remaining outlets going overkill with the song.
 
Cody Johnson, breakout star of 2022-23 with his hits "Til You Can't" and "Human," is firmly in the Aldean camp. It's hard to see anyone significant in the genre right now criticizing the song or video. Radio seems to be on board with Aldean 100 percent and this is shaping up as a "go woke, go broke" situation for anyone who dares speak out. The most that can be expected from Tim McGraw, Garth Brooks, Miranda Lambert (although she did have a hit duet with Aldean a couple of years ago) and any other left-of-center country stars is silence.

 
Jason Aldean at Woodstock! Well, Bethel, New York, actually, a week or so ago. He seems to go over well with this small town crowd despite going off key remarkably often for a song that doesn't exactly test one's vocal range. The comments are, well, pretty much what you'd expect.
 
I only quoted the Back the Blue event,,,which is in the video. The other person tried to gaslight by stating untrue comments.
Bill, my purpose here is not to tell lies or make untrue comments. I'm trying to interpret a video which you sent and which confused the members here, because it was sent without any context whatsoever. I apologize for conflating two separate events, but there is no possible way to discern that without some context provided for the video.
If you know what is happening in a video, then please provide written context for the video at the same time that you post it. That way, everyone can get an accurate account of what is happening. -- Daryl
 
Having grown up in a small town, my experience is that there is an "in-group" and an "out-group." If you are part of the dominant race, the dominant culture, the dominant religion, or the dominant economic class of the town, then you are part of the in-group.
If not, then you are part of the out-group and are looked upon with suspicion or mistrust. So if you are part of the out-group, you have to work very hard to gain the in-group's trust and acceptance.

It's true that a small town will stand up for the in-group and will support them. But the out-group is strictly on their own, as it is believed that they should not live there in the first place.

I spent my teens growing up in a small town and I applaud your excellent assessment. That was exactly my observation and experience too.

I don't think the songwriters on this release meant to sound provincial and shunning, but I can understand why it would be perceived that way. JMO.

I think the songwriters knew exactly what they were doing. The lyrics aren't exactly subtle and the song's intent is hardly complicated. I heard a rightwing anthem in the making from the very first listen, well before the video was even released and the CMT controversy ensued. I don't think the marketing team could written a better script than what we're seeing now. Or maybe they did. JMO.
 
I just received the Billboard Hot Country Chart, and they report that after CMT dropped the video for Try That In a Small Town, streaming for the song increased to the point where it jumped to #1. This is the Hot Country chart, not the airplay chart. The Hot Country chart measures airplay and streaming.

 
Sir, the post you shared, sounded as if you were there. The town is not 99% White, as you claim. I am curious, do you support BLM & Antifa?
Bill, I support the right of peaceful protest and peaceful assembly, which is provided for us in the Constitution. If the protest turns violent, or if people are injured, then I am opposed to that.
Yes, I agree, the town in 90.9% white. However, the Radio Discussions board has members from all over the world. It's difficult to make sense of a video that has no explanation attached to it. When you post a video, please explain what is happening in the video. This is helpful to everyone, especially to people in other countries who are trying to understand why the video is relevant to the discussion.
 
I thought this was a country music thread
No, it is about banning a Country Song based on its video depicting scenes of urban violence, many of which involved Blacks.
 
No, it is about banning a Country Song based on its video depicting scenes of urban violence, many of which involved Blacks.
"The clips came from real events or news footage, but many did not take place in the U.S. They included scenes of protests in Ukraine, Spain, Germany and Canada, one as far back as 2010":

 
"The clips came from real events or news footage, but many did not take place in the U.S. They included scenes of protests in Ukraine, Spain, Germany and Canada, one as far back as 2010":
'Yep, just goes to show, we wouldn't let any of that furnanure protest activity go on in our town neither."
 
I know right? When I saw the terms BLM and Antifa being thrown around, I thought; 'oh, here we go'.
Yeah, when I saw "Antifa" come up it was like, "Nah, I'm staying out of this one. I'd rather visit a sewage treatment plant." Which I will be doing later today.

I'm not joking.
 
Yeah, when I saw "Antifa" come up it was like, "Nah, I'm staying out of this one. I'd rather visit a sewage treatment plant." Which I will be doing later today.

I'm not joking.
I ought to react the same way when I see antifa cast in the role of terrifying bogeyman, but sometimes my fingers work faster than my brain. I'm still regretting taking the bait yesterday. My comment (since deleted -- thanks, Frank) directed at Mr. Betten was uncalled for.
 
Sir, no worries. I am requesting all my comments in the thread be removed. Been on the Forum for 14 years and there is no reason to start engaging in politics. Have a good day.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.


Back
Top Bottom