F.M.Hertz said:
I will stand by this argument until the day I die, but I believe that Leno was behind all of this,a nd isn't the nice guy that he wants everyone to think he is. He should have stepped aside, and done maybe 4 to 6 specials during the year like Bob Hope or Jack Benny used to do. Simply, if NBC promoted Conan and gave him a chance, he'd still be the host of NBC's 11:35 show.
Why should Jay have retired or semi-retired? Jay was the bad guy in the early 90's, but I think Conan was more the bad guy here. Lets run down what happened from the start.
2004 Conan demands tonight show spot, or threatens to goto FOX or ABC who at the time were trying to get him. NBC doesn't want that, but doesn't want Conan as tonight show host yet either. NBC in all its wisdom thinks that in 5 yrs Jay will be ready to retire, and his ratings will be ready to decline. So a agreement is made between Conan & NBC, that in 5 yrs Conan will take over the tonight show. Jay was probably not happy, but he plays the company man and acts happy about it. Perhaps at the time he figured in 5 yrs i will probably be ready to retire anyway.
All is well for 4 yr.
2008 Jay realizes he doesn't want to retire & ABC wants him.
NBC seeing Jay's ratings are still strong start beeping their pants at the idea of Jay on ABC, just as they did 4 yrs before when ABC was trying to get Conan.
Someone at NBC had the brilliant idea to save some money by scraping 10:00 prime time programing, and havning Leno.
NBC offers Leno a boatload of money to do 10:00 show. Conan was probably not happy, but he plays the company man and acts happy about it.
All is well again
Conan starts tonight show. After a strong 1st week ratings take a dive.
Conan blames the fact that it is summer on the decline, but Letterman repeats were beating him.
Jay's new show starts & is a flop
Both Jay & Conan's show are struggling. Conan now blames the weak Leno leadin for why his show is struggling.
NBC realizes it made a mistake about not programing 10:00PM, but can't fire Leno because his contract is gaurenteed
Conan on the otherhand had a stipulation that the network could delay his show as late as 12:05
So NBC decided to move Jay's show to 11:35, but shorten it to a 1/2 hr & tonight show to start at 12:05.
Jay agrees, but Conan not happy. Network tells Conan to take it or leave it.
Conan leaves & tonight show becomes Jay's again.
So outside not ready to retire how is Jay at fault? I mean I will give him a little blame, but out of the 3 parties I think he deserves the least. Fact is if Conan hadn't tried to bump him off back in 04, none of this would've happened. Conan would probably be on the verge of getting the tonight show now, or would be 8 yrs into a fox/abc run battling it out with Leno/Letterman