What a neat thread you started, Sherlock!
Google
Joey Reynolds and enjoy reading any one of these classic Joey Reynolds links.
Like most Western New York radio rug rats, I listened to Joey in his glory days at WKBW, which featured the great change-overs with Dan Neaverth that usually lasted at least five minutes with plenty of "inside" stuff, the wacky bits and characters like "the engaged woman." It was the Royal order of the Night, purple candles and all. I think we're all the better for having heard Joey in his prime.
Though I haven't spoken to him in years, I've known Joey personally since 1986 when I worked with him when he filled in doing mornings at WNYS and Classic Hits WHTT when Sandy Beach went on vacation. (Jay Thomas also did a few weeks of fill-in in the WNYS days, until he pissed off the entire community of Depew with one of his bits.)
Reynolds went into syndication in 1996 on the WOR Network, doing his all night show from New York and WGR was one of the first stations to sign him... really, how hard of a decision was
that! He was pure gold. There were many nights when his show sounded like it originated from Buffalo rather than the Big Apple.
WGR brought Joey to town for the Buffalo Broadcasters ceremony when he was inducted to the Hall of Fame, along with Liz Dribbon, formerly of Channel 7's Dialing For Dollars, who was frequently the brunt of Joey's bits on KB radio.
It was a classic night. Ask Al Wallack and any number of radio people who were there. When Dribbon, after her introduction, asked for and received a chair to "make a few comments" we knew it was gonna be a long night. Most of the people in the audience were waiting for Joey to be inducted. Envision people in the audience checking their watches (which seemed to be running backwards) as Liz, god bless her, told story after story after... all the while sitting in that big chair on stage.
After a while, Liz yielded the stage to Joey, who was introduced by Larry Norton. The first thing Reynolds says (after dramatically looking at HIS wristwatch) was, "I've been waiting so long to get up here tonight, I think the
Kiss morning show is ready to be inducted into the Hall of Fame!" Big laughs. He went on to tell a few stories and had the audience in the pam of his hand.
I don't think the Times article did justice to Joey and his career. I don't understand the comments from the WOR staff. They were kind of insensitive. Maybe they were trying to be humorous, but their comments sounded more disparaging than graceful and complimentary. It could have been a better story.
As to Joey's early career before KB, I was sure he did a stint at WHOT-AM 1330, Campbell-Youngstown, Ohio before he hit Syracuse. The stories on this thread of him leaving KB in 1966 are classics... and true.
It was Jeff Kaye who came from WBZ Boston to succeed Reynolds on the 7-midnight shift at KB around 1966. The "Jeff Kaye Underground" replaced the Royal Order of the Night.
The rest is history, and a great chapter of Buffalo radio history it is.