On spice and flavor records, I agree. But to some an " Oh Wow" record is " Oh Crap". My answer is have a flavor /spice category, but you gotta test them. The top 4 stations in this market all test their music.Some test their libraries twice a year some once, but " the big four" here all test.Plus call out for currents, if they play them.
I've personally watched songs test in the top 100 with good scores in a 600 song study and six months later, the same song in the bottom 100, and six months later a high score again.
As to the Seattle Oldies station that played the same song two dayparts later, I agree that either was a poorly programmed station, a jock breaking format or a special request. Often tightly formatted stations like Oldies, AC or Classic Rock repeat the midday Music log from 12 mid to 5a to give the rotations a rest. But most have a 5 daypart separation: middays today,PM drive tomorrow.And always tested music...even the spice records.Otherwise it's radio geeks like us deciding what the masses want.And in this competitive intolerant era, that does not work.
Yes...there was no tested music in the Glory days of WARM, but it was s simpler time.WARM had it's best test of all...record sales. Yeah they broke a record or two, but I understand it was a very " safe station". The WSCR's and WBAX's of the world were the rebel stations,weren't they?.No cable TV, internet,Ipods, CD's,DVD's,gameboys,X Box's, get my point?
It seemed a simpler time because it WAS a simpler time.This is one that " time has NOT rewritten every line".The days of 30,40,50 shares are gone. Even the biggest of big stations " only" has a 10 share nowadays. That means 90 % of the town doesn't listen to them.