I really think this area needs an Active Rock station - one that clearly targets Men under the age of 50. This station needs to play the more aggressive music that other stations around here ignore (including WRAT - have they ever played Slipknot or Sevendust?), mixing it up with some mainstream rock and a few classic rock acts for good measure - I think they should go for a sound similar to WZBH (93.5 The Beach) in Delaware or 101.1 WJRR in the Orlando market.
Basically, we have Country covered - 98.5 and Cat Country 107.1 overlap much of the market, and 98.5 doesn't reach far enough into Monmouth County to draw significant ratings with that format. We have the '60s & '70s covered (although an Oldies station that plays '50s and '60s wouldn't be a bad idea, especially in this market). A Smooth Jazz station with a big signal failed, but maybe it would work on a smaller scale. I'd listen to an Urban station, but I don't know if it would work in a predominantly Caucasian area like Ocean County. We've got enough Hot ACs and Classic Rockers in the area, that's for sure. CHR was attempted with less than stellar ratings, and WAYV is fairly close to that sound anyway (during the week at least). AC would potentially take ratings away from The Breeze. A station that's too Alternative sounding would hurt G Rock Radio. Then again, G Rock's lighter take on Alternative may lose the interest of listeners seeking edgier sounds that are often heard on other stations with the format. This is why an Active Rock station would work in the market - with G Rock being too soft for some listeners and WRAT being too soft / too classic for others (and not reaching Ocean County all that well), there's a whole audience here that is served by no one. It's a great opportunity, and someone needs to take advantage.
Either Oldies or edgier Active Rock would be a fantastic format for 98.5. But I don't expect either - I think we're far more likely to get another Country station or Classic Rocker.