Props to joemamma for nailing the exact date of the flip. When I saw that post the first thing that came to my mind was KKLZ switching to oldies. It's the obvious hole. I thought the only other possibility was CHR/Pop. Beasley could have tried to put the squeeze on MIX with CHR on one side and STAR on the other. But oldies is the better choice of the two, especially to reach 25-54.
I am a believer in this updated 70s based oldies format. KQOL had very good numbers at the end of their run. By updating their music KQOL lowered their demos too. The problem was that they had the stigma of being known as an "oldies" station for so many years. This is not so much a problem with listeners, but for advertisers the word "oldies" is the kiss of death. "Classic Hits" is a much more advertising friendly term, KKLZ is very smart to use that term. Besides, no matter how old the 70s era music get's..it just doesn't sound like what most people think of as "oldies". Even if KKLZ does play some 60s product, "classic hits" is by far the better name to use.
Whenever there is a format flip I always think about which stations willl benefit and which stations will get hurt. I think that Lotus is going to benefit most from this flip. KOMP is going to get a ton of the displaced KKLZ listeners. KOMP plays plenty of hard classic rock that will appeal to the former KKLZ audience. Look for KOMP to become an even bigger 25-54 male monster than they are already.
Of course Lotus's KXPT will also get a lot of the KKLZ audience. KXPT is not only #1 for classic rock, they are now the only classic rock station. If the POINT tweaks a little harder they will gain even more KKLZ listeners. But since KOMP is their sister station they may not need to get harder, Lotus can't go wrong in this situation. However I do think the migration will work both ways with KXPT. Some POINT listeners were using the station as a default oldies station and will switch to KKLZ. Let's not forget that the POINT called themselves "Classic Hits" for many many years.
Another station that could benefit, and they could use the good news, is JACK. As I mentioned in a previous post, KKJJ is more rock than ever. This will help them attract displaced KKLZ listeners.
As far as what stations will suffer from this flip? I would say any station that does well 45-54...SUNNY, both Country stations, maybe even the OASIS. However because I expect KKLZ to steal or share audience from a variety of stations, I don't think that any one individual station will get hurt too bad from this flip.
A couple other notes. Charlie Logan is out as PD of KKLZ. I thought he did a good job steering KKLZ towards a comeback, but the station was long past dead before he even got there...I heard that Mike O"Brian will still be doing mornings, he seems like a good fit for the format. Also, Pat Garret is the station voice, I think his sweepers sound great. I never heard him on a non-rhythmic CHR until now. Both KLUC and HOT have used him in the past.