pattiwacki said:
What I can't appreciate is a formerly great station sounding awful and clueless, throwing different kinds of songs from different eras at the wall to see what will stick until there's just a big mess left. Sorry.
You and I probably describe a "big mess" differently. My mp3 player has a combination of songs which would sound natural to me if played on KOOL. They range from Fats and Rick Nelson to the Everlys and Beach Boys followed by some Elton John and even Enya. Toss in a few country-rock favs, a doo-wop or two, some Moody Blues and CSN&Y and I'm in music heaven. Very little Motown, if any, no metal and virtually nothing post-1980. I don't consider this a "mess" but also recognize it would be almost impossible to brand using the normal descriptions. Maybe "Whatever We Want" comes closest (although they didn't play "whatever I wanted" either).
Oldies, to me, means early RnR (late 50's), surf, British Invasion, Folk Rock and 70's rock. That covers a ton of music history and playlists could be large and varied. If I were KOOL PD that would be my target, complete with jingles, effects and DJ soundbites appropriate to that era. It would be the greatest oldies radio station on Earth! (regardless of what Eduardo says)