I'm not sure there's a comparison to Star and Click, though I haven't been in the market to listen to Star lately. When I did hear Star in January, the playlist sounded pretty typical for them, with a few new songs thrown in that I didn't know. However, the new personalities and voice make the thing sound completely wrong. I am not sure if they can recover or whether those changes will be the station's downfall, only time will tell. Given the track record of Lisa Adams in this market, they'll probably replace her in a year and then flip a year later.