No PD who has had success playing all Christmas music this early before is going to suddenly stick to his guns & say it's too early. First of all, it isn't too early. Retail is into Christmas already. Christmas movies are being released. It's part of the whole atmosphere. My only problem with playing all Christmas remains that to avoid repetition you're forced to play some of the most generic songs imaginable, or at least some of the most needless, generic versions of well-known songs imaginable. You can be more selective by limiting the playlist and working the songs in gradually, but precedents have been established & it isn't going to change. A lot of it is background anyway so who's singing what doesn't matter that much.