Hi Matt,
I've done Part 15 (and am still doing it) and I've done carrier-current..but I never have tried
to match a Part 15 system with a c-c box.
In my situation, the Part 15 system (I have a Rangemaster) has worked better than my previous c-c system.
I'm off the beaten path, in the back of a 17 acre farm. At the time, I didn't know about neutral injection, and a transformer stopped the signal before it got out of my yard.
I still have an LPB c-c box wired in on the meter pole out back..haven't used it since 1995! I barely got
1/4 mile out of it in the daytime, and that was with a 30-watt LPB xmitter.