• Get involved.
    We want your input!
    Apply for Membership and join the conversations about everything related to broadcasting.

    After we receive your registration, a moderator will review it. After your registration is approved, you will be permitted to post.
    If you use a disposable or false email address, your registration will be rejected.

    After your membership is approved, please take a minute to tell us a little bit about yourself.
    https://www.radiodiscussions.com/forums/introduce-yourself.1088/

    Thanks in advance and have fun!
    RadioDiscussions Administrators

Market and affiliation changes, cable/satellite carriage, and more

I'm starting this thread to discuss the following topics:
  • Changes in television markets (DMA/ADI), including the shift of counties from one market to another
  • Cable and satellite carriage of in-market and out-of-market stations, including the "orphan county" situations
  • Carriage of multiple network affiliates on cable and satellite in various markets
  • Small "infill" markets (Alpena, Harrisonburg, Parkersburg, et cetera) and "short" markets
  • Stations that serve portions of a market as well as neighboing markets (e.g., WYMT Hazard KY, WWJS/WHKY Hickory NC, and so on)
  • How these scenarios were handled by the annual directories such as Broadcasting Yearbook and Television Factbook
Discussion of such topics often involve more than one market, therefore it is difficult to contain them without lapsing into "thread drift".

Let's get this show on the road!
 
Before WBKB came on the air in Alpena, Alpena County was in the Traverse City/Cadillac ADI (WGTU had a translator there for a while in the 70s and 80s) while Alcona County was in the Flint/Saginaw/Bay City ADI (but still preferred TC/C for CBS, along with most of the northerly counties of the Flint/Saginaw ADI).

I recall seeing somewhere online (not sure where) of the top 100 market ADIs in the late 1950s and Manistee and Mason counties in Michigan were in the Green Bay market; at this time, WPBN was still broadcasting from a short tower near Traverse City (WZZM didn't come on until 1962).

Marquette had de facto two FOX affiliates from 1995 to 2012 (except for a few months in 2009):
1995-2003: WLUK (Green Bay - had existing cable carriage as an NBC affiliate as WLUC only had a secondary NBC affiliation) and WGKI/WFQX (Cadillac - replaced WKBD in most of Michigan after WKBD dropped FOX)
2003-June 2009: WLUK and WMQF (replaced WFQX on most central/western UP cable systems at launch - most systems picked it up off of Galaxy 18)
June-August 2009: WLUK only
August 2009-2012: WLUK and WLUC-DT2 (eventually, WLUC-DT2 would take WLUK's cable slots on most systems with WLUK moving to a higher channel before the grandfather clause that allowed WLUK widespread cable carriage in the UP expired in 2012).

Ironically, the former WMQF (which was very cheaply run during its original stint on air), as WZMQ, is probably the most successful of the former Equity stations as it landed the CBS affiliation in 2022.
 
I didn't want to spend money on cable before digital TV made it almost a necessity (I might get good results with an outdoor antenna but so far I haven't tried). I'm considered to be in the Charlotte market though with an antenna four Greensboro stations are closer than some of the Charlotte stations.

But I seem to recall WGHP Greensboro NC (Fox, previously ABC) was on our cable system before I got cable. Now only WFMY {CBS) is on my cable system from that market. The next county over has WGHP, I believe. The radio station in that county used to have weather forecasts from WGHP's best known meteorologist, though that may because the owner had previously worked in the Greensboro market. Now it has forecasts from WBTV's chief meteorologist.
 
I didn't want to spend money on cable before digital TV made it almost a necessity (I might get good results with an outdoor antenna but so far I haven't tried). I'm considered to be in the Charlotte market though with an antenna four Greensboro stations are closer than some of the Charlotte stations.

But I seem to recall WGHP Greensboro NC (Fox, previously ABC) was on our cable system before I got cable. Now only WFMY {CBS) is on my cable system from that market. The next county over has WGHP, I believe. The radio station in that county used to have weather forecasts from WGHP's best known meteorologist, though that may because the owner had previously worked in the Greensboro market. Now it has forecasts from WBTV's chief meteorologist.

If that is Rowan County, indeed, it is another one of those "neither fish nor fowl" situations. It could just as easily be in the Triad market as Charlotte, but a county has to be in one market and one market only, so for whatever reason, Charlotte got elected. Stanly County, and arguably Davie County, is in much the same situation. Further north, Wilkes County is another. Davie County is closer to the Triad, but still close enough to Charlotte for viable reception, ditto Wilkes. Montgomery County is another such county, once Charlotte, now Triad. At one time, the populations of the two metro areas were not as sharply different as they are today, nor was Charlotte nearly as large or as nationally significant as it is today.

WCNC still has a translator in Biscoe, not sure if WXII has ever had an issue with that, keep in mind, too, WXII's transmitter is fairly far to the north and west in King NC. In analog days, WXII's projected Grade B contour just nicked the corner of West Virginia around Princeton, though with better measuring techniques such as Longley-Rice heat maps, we can now see that linear contours are just rough estimates. At one time WXII (then WSJS) and WFMY were carried on Bluefield cable.
 
One interesting change over the decades within a DMA is in Arkansas where there one-time Fort Smith market is now the Fort Smith-Fayetteville-Springdale-Rogers market. The network affiliates were originally all based in Fort Smith. Now they all have their primary studios and main news operations in the Fayetteville/Northwest Arkansas area. With Walmart's epic growth and the University of Arkansas, Fayetteville and the other NWA cities have long passed the Fort Smith metro in size. As a result, the stations have all relocated -- essentially, the old NWA satellite TV stations are operating as the primary outlets (KFSM 5 excluded since it was the lone commercial analog VHF that could cover both markets with its signal and never had a NWA relay; though, it too has moved its primary studio from Fort Smith).
 
Back in the late 70s, Dayton, Ohio was struggling to stay in the top 50 (it is now market #64). Dayton TV shared audience in Mercer County with Fort Wayne, Indiana and Clinton County, Ohio with Cincinnati. The 3 Dayton TV stations ran radio and newspaper ads in those counties. "Channels 2, 7 and 22. So much more for you". In the case of Mercer County, 22 didn't even have cable coverage. If there was a cow out of a barn in those 2 counties, a news crew was there. Ultimately it didn't help.
 
Back in the late 70s, Dayton, Ohio was struggling to stay in the top 50 (it is now market #64). Dayton TV shared audience in Mercer County with Fort Wayne, Indiana and Clinton County, Ohio with Cincinnati. The 3 Dayton TV stations ran radio and newspaper ads in those counties. "Channels 2, 7 and 22. So much more for you". In the case of Mercer County, 22 didn't even have cable coverage. If there was a cow out of a barn in those 2 counties, a news crew was there. Ultimately it didn't help.
The Dayton market is one of the highest OTA-only markets in the U.S., around 25% of TV homes. The nearby Cincinnati market comes in at 22%.

I used to live in Warren county which is the county between the Cincinnati and Dayton markets. I could be wrong, but I seem to recall that at one time, Warren county was a “split county” in terms of the two DMAs — northern Warren County was the Dayton DMA, with the south part of the county in the Cincinnati DMA.

(With Cincinnati and Dayton being so close to each other, it was beyond easy for me in Warren county to pick up both cities’ stations at local grade — plus with Columbus being at 60-70 miles, reception of that city’s stations was also achievable from my location)
 
One interesting change over the decades within a DMA is in Arkansas where there one-time Fort Smith market is now the Fort Smith-Fayetteville-Springdale-Rogers market. The network affiliates were originally all based in Fort Smith. Now they all have their primary studios and main news operations in the Fayetteville/Northwest Arkansas area. With Walmart's epic growth and the University of Arkansas, Fayetteville and the other NWA cities have long passed the Fort Smith metro in size. As a result, the stations have all relocated -- essentially, the old NWA satellite TV stations are operating as the primary outlets (KFSM 5 excluded since it was the lone commercial analog VHF that could cover both markets with its signal and never had a NWA relay; though, it too has moved its primary studio from Fort Smith).

I don't know why I thought those were two separate markets. Were they at one time?

This sounds very similar to what happened with the Florence-Myrtle Beach market in South Carolina. At one time, there was only one station in Florence, WBTW-13, and it was primary CBS with some ABC (and maybe NBC if you go back far enough), and two stations in Wilmington, WWAY-3 and WECT-6 (ABC and NBC respectively, with the odd CBS show on WECT). Horry County (MB) was in the Wilmington market until 1983 when it flipped to Florence (about the time WPDE-15, ABC, went on the air, WWAY threw a fit and even filed a complaint with the FCC) and has been there ever since. However, with the explosive growth in the Myrtle Beach area in the years following, the center of gravity shifted, MB gained Fox and later NBC affiliates, and the Florence stations, for all practical purposes, moved to the MB area. They are still licensed to Florence, and the sticks for WBTW, WPDE, and WWMB (UPN and later CW affiliate) are at Hamer SC, near South of the Border (for those who don't know, it's a wildly popular, or at least it used to be, faux-Mexican mini-theme park with a motor hotel, camping, restaurants, and so on), which makes for the curious situation of Myrtle Beach-based stations having their towers some 50 miles inland, and, yes, that does create reception issues sometimes.

OTA reception of most Wilmington (as well as Charleston) stations is possible with a decent outdoor antenna in MB (actually easier to get than Hamer), but Wilmington might as well be on another planet, their world ends at the NC/SC line. Only PBS NC is carried on cable. Oddly enough, just a few miles down the coast from MB, Georgetown County, the Charleston market begins. Georgetown is a very long county and IMO should be split, with "Georgetown North" being Florence-Myrtle Beach, and "Georgetown South" being Charleston, but that hasn't happened and may never. WPDE, though curiously not WBTW, shows up as significantly viewed in a couple of resort towns and Georgetown city on the 2016 SV list, and WFXB (Fox affiliate licensed to MB, one of the Bahakel stations) shows up as SV for the whole county. Go figure. I'm assuming the satellite providers furnish only Charleston locals for the entire county, which means that for local news in places such as Murrells Inlet, I guess folks have to go out and buy an antenna. Again, the county really needs to be split for DMA purposes.

I lived in Myrtle Beach in 1996 and 1997 and watched stations from all three cities, though for local news, we always preferred WPDE. (Gordon Barnes was at the place where I took my ham radio license test.) At that time, WPDE was more "the Myrtle Beach station" and WBTW was "the Florence station", but they, too, have moved their main studios to the MB area.
 
Last edited:
The Dayton market is one of the highest OTA-only markets in the U.S., around 25% of TV homes. The nearby Cincinnati market comes in at 22%.

I used to live in Warren county which is the county between the Cincinnati and Dayton markets. I could be wrong, but I seem to recall that at one time, Warren county was a “split county” in terms of the two DMAs — northern Warren County was the Dayton DMA, with the south part of the county in the Cincinnati DMA.

(With Cincinnati and Dayton being so close to each other, it was beyond easy for me in Warren county to pick up both cities’ stations at local grade — plus with Columbus being at 60-70 miles, reception of that city’s stations was also achievable from my location)

Warren County was indeed split at one time the way you describe. Dayton is in the curious situation of having fairly strong signals from Cincinnati in the center city (and vice versa), with Columbus reception being possible in some spots, but having a hinterland to the north where Dayton (and possibly Lima if you get far enough north) is the only OTA TV easily available. I have to wonder if the high OTA percentage is due to a critical mass of viewers being able to get two (and possibly three) markets OTA with all of those subchannels. They may have figured out that with a boatload of subchannels, some not duplicated, and streaming, they don't need to bother paying for TV (aside from subscription costs for the premium channels if they go that route).
 
Back in the late 70s, Dayton, Ohio was struggling to stay in the top 50 (it is now market #64). Dayton TV shared audience in Mercer County with Fort Wayne, Indiana and Clinton County, Ohio with Cincinnati. The 3 Dayton TV stations ran radio and newspaper ads in those counties. "Channels 2, 7 and 22. So much more for you". In the case of Mercer County, 22 didn't even have cable coverage. If there was a cow out of a barn in those 2 counties, a news crew was there. Ultimately it didn't help.

This sounds like what the Lexington KY stations did in the 1970s, ran promos on the three stations with the call letters and channel numbers for all three at the bottom of the screen and the slogan "Lexington Television - A Reflection Of You". As I noted elsewhere, a case of a rising tide lifting all boats.
 
Warren County was indeed split at one time the way you describe. Dayton is in the curious situation of having fairly strong signals from Cincinnati in the center city (and vice versa), with Columbus reception being possible in some spots, but having a hinterland to the north where Dayton (and possibly Lima if you get far enough north) is the only OTA TV easily available. I have to wonder if the high OTA percentage is due to a critical mass of viewers being able to get two (and possibly three) markets OTA with all of those subchannels. They may have figured out that with a boatload of subchannels, some not duplicated, and streaming, they don't need to bother paying for TV (aside from subscription costs for the premium channels if they go that route).
The higher OTA-only percentage probably has more to do about the Dayton DMA/region not being as affluent as compared to others, as evidenced by companies and manufacturers (i.e., jobs) pulling out of that area over the years/decades. Plus, that area is known nationally for its problems with drugs, meth., etc., to the point that PBS did a documentary on Dayton in this regard.

Sad what has happened to Dayton.
 
This sounds very similar to what happened with the Florence-Myrtle Beach market in South Carolina. At one time, there was only one station in Florence, WBTW-13, and it was primary CBS with some ABC (and maybe NBC if you go back far enough), and two stations in Wilmington, WWAY-3 and WECT-6 (ABC and NBC respectively, with the odd CBS show on WECT). Horry County (MB) was in the Wilmington market until 1983 when it flipped to Florence (about the time WPDE-15, ABC, went on the air, WWAY threw a fit and even filed a complaint with the FCC) and has been there ever since. However, with the explosive growth in the Myrtle Beach area in the years following, the center of gravity shifted, MB gained Fox and later NBC affiliates, and the Florence stations, for all practical purposes, moved to the MB area. They are still licensed to Florence, and the sticks for WBTW, WPDE, and WWMB (UPN and later CW affiliate) are at Hamer SC, near South of the Border (for those who don't know, it's a wildly popular, or at least it used to be, faux-Mexican mini-theme park with a motor hotel, camping, restaurants, and so on), which makes for the curious situation of Myrtle Beach-based stations having their towers some 50 miles inland, and, yes, that does create reception issues sometimes.
Just to clarify, it wasn't a case of WWAY objecting to Horry County flipping to Florence (though I'm sure they had very strong feelings about that too), but a new ABC affiliate being in Florence. I can't find the reference, but unless I dreamed it or something, WWAY filed a complaint with the FCC, saying that an ABC affiliate so close to them would harm WWAY, which obviously it did. I want to say it was in Broadcasting Magazine, but I can't swear to that. I tried the search function on World Radio History but couldn't find anything.

My question is, can the FCC even get involved in such disputes? Isn't it the prerogative of the stations and the network to decide with whom a network will affiliate? In any event, it came to naught, though I'd imagine that if a cable provider on either side of the border carried both, they'd have to sim-sub the OOM station if the home market station demanded it. As a practical matter, carriage of one or the other pretty much ends at the NC/SC border, Robeson County (FMB market) excepted. Per TVTV.com, Spectrum there carries WTVD as an alternate ABC affiliate, along with WRAL. That would be far preferable for in-state viewing than Wilmington stations. (As a side note, TVTV lists WECT as still being carried in Dunn and Fayetteville. I was in Dunn in 2009 and Fayetteville around 2016, and both were still carried then. Evidently it is a carry-over from when WECT billed itself as "Wilmington-Fayetteville", and had its tower fairly far inland, between the two cities.)
 
Last edited:
Warren County was indeed split at one time the way you describe. Dayton is in the curious situation of having fairly strong signals from Cincinnati in the center city (and vice versa), with Columbus reception being possible in some spots, but having a hinterland to the north where Dayton (and possibly Lima if you get far enough north) is the only OTA TV easily available. I have to wonder if the high OTA percentage is due to a critical mass of viewers being able to get two (and possibly three) markets OTA with all of those subchannels. They may have figured out that with a boatload of subchannels, some not duplicated, and streaming, they don't need to bother paying for TV (aside from subscription costs for the premium channels if they go that route).
A couple of years ago, I stayed at a hotel across I-71 from Kings Island (which is in Warren County) and I brought along my little portable ATSC TV. It was able to pick up most signals from both Cincinnati and Dayton with just the included antenna.

Speaking of counties that could easily be split, Polk County, FL is the first example that comes to mind. The county is in the Tampa DMA, but the northeast portion of the county is home to many hotels/motels that cater to Disney travelers, as well as likely some Disney employees. Based on that, Davenport, Haines City, and the Polk County portion of Poinciana (most of Poinciana is in Osceola County - Orlando market) should be in the Orlando market. I've never stayed in any of those NE Polk hotels, but I wouldn't be surprised if a few have private MATV systems to pick up Orlando stations alongside (or instead of) the Tampa stations.
 
A couple of years ago, I stayed at a hotel across I-71 from Kings Island (which is in Warren County) and I brought along my little portable ATSC TV. It was able to pick up most signals from both Cincinnati and Dayton with just the included antenna.

Speaking of counties that could easily be split, Polk County, FL is the first example that comes to mind. The county is in the Tampa DMA, but the northeast portion of the county is home to many hotels/motels that cater to Disney travelers, as well as likely some Disney employees. Based on that, Davenport, Haines City, and the Polk County portion of Poinciana (most of Poinciana is in Osceola County - Orlando market) should be in the Orlando market. I've never stayed in any of those NE Polk hotels, but I wouldn't be surprised if a few have private MATV systems to pick up Orlando stations alongside (or instead of) the Tampa stations.

Polk County absolutely should be split, northeast/southwest. My son and I stayed in Davenport, just inside the Polk County line, when we went to Disney World, and the cable there carried Tampa stations along with WFTV-9 from Orlando, and maybe another station, don't recall which. I didn't have my equipment with me to try and see what from either market I could receive.

One interesting split that occurred in the 1960s (per TVFB) was Guilford County NC (Greensboro), split between "Guilford Inner" (Greensboro and environs) and "Guilford Outer" (everything else). Both WRAL Raleigh and WSOC Charlotte are listed as having 5-24% coverage in Guilford Outer and nothing in Guilford Inner. WDBJ and WSLS Roanoke show up as having 5-24% in both portions. The WRAL and WSOC situations are ironic in that High Point (WGHP, ABC) is in Guilford County. WGHP only went on the air in 1963, so perhaps viewers were still used to getting ABC from Raleigh and Charlotte, and hadn't yet totally changed their viewing habits (but what, then, of Greensboro viewers?). The 1966 TVFB also listed Guilford Inner and Guilford Outer, but for some reason that edition of TVFB didn't break out percentages of coverage, all counties simply appeared in gray. Neither the 1963 nor 1968 TVFBs broke out Guilford into two parts. I don't have access to any other TVFBs from that era. (But I am always on the lookout.)
 
so perhaps viewers were still used to getting ABC from Raleigh and Charlotte, and hadn't yet totally changed their viewing habits (but what, then, of Greensboro viewers?). The 1966 TVFB also listed Guilford Inner and Guilford Outer, but for some reason that edition of TVFB didn't break out percentages of coverage, all counties simply appeared in gray. Neither the 1963 nor 1968 TVFBs broke out Guilford into two parts. I don't have access to any other TVFBs from that era. (But I am always on the lookout.)
WSOC was NBC and ABC. I don't recall what percentage of their programming was ABC in the days before WGHP, but by the time I lived in the area, I don't recall anything other than NBC programming.
 
WSOC was NBC and ABC. I don't recall what percentage of their programming was ABC in the days before WGHP, but by the time I lived in the area, I don't recall anything other than NBC programming.

You are right, I was asleep at the wheel, just assumed that WSOC was full-ABC because it is now. I knew otherwise but didn't think of it. I'm assuming that WSOC was primary NBC.

WRAL got a rimshot signal into Greensboro, while WSOC's Grade B contours just miss the city. Oddly, WTVD reached Greensboro as well, but doesn't show up with any ARB data for 1967. To this day, Greensboro and Durham stations can reach each other's core cities with a halfway-decent antenna, and if there were no Winston-Salem or Raleigh, Greensboro-Durham would make perfect sense as a market.

WLVA (now WSET) would have been kind of a reach. The 1967 TVFB doesn't show any data for them in either part of Guilford.
 
WLVA (now WSET) would have been kind of a reach. The 1967 TVFB doesn't show any data for them in either part of Guilford.
I lived north of Greensboro during the first season of "The Partridge Family" and heard the show on WLVA. It was interesting when WGHP finally showed the same episodes when they were reruns and I could see what happened.
 
I lived north of Greensboro during the first season of "The Partridge Family" and heard the show on WLVA. It was interesting when WGHP finally showed the same episodes when they were reruns and I could see what happened.

What was the matter with the picture?
 
Status
This thread has been closed due to inactivity. You can create a new thread to discuss this topic.


Back
Top Bottom