The BIGGEST problem is that when you have mediocre programmers like Jan Jeffries & Jim Kennedy calling the shots, you're doomed for failure....They were handed an aging, but still viable format with Oldies and they STILL found a way to screw it up..even though the demos weren't great, they were still the best numbers they've had..
Even though the flip to Classic hits was'nt too bright (why would you want to be the 4th rock station in the market?) I wouldn't let the PD off the hook too easily..the audio, the imaging, and the air staff are a mess, and that's his area..