I think you are correct.
> > What did Magic do wrong?
> >
> > Whats their problem?
>
> They should have kept the normal AC playlist going until
> Christmas Eve. Ratings around the country generally prove
> that if the market-leading station took an early jump on an
> all-Christmas format, then other stations which also go
> all-Christmas had no hope of catching up. After all,
> Christmas music is Christmas music, and if you tune your
> office or store radio to one station in mid-November when
> they go all-Christmas (i.e. WLTW), then you're not likely to
> switch to any other station when they also go all-Christmas
> a few weeks later (i.e. WMGQ). BUT... there would be an
> open opportunity for that second station to continue with a
> regular AC playlist, to pick up all the listeners who
> deserted the market-leading station when it went
> all-Christmas. That's the opportunity which WMGQ missed by
> switching to its own "me-too" all-Christmas format after
> Thanksgiving.
>