• Get involved.
    We want your input!
    Apply for Membership and join the conversations about everything related to broadcasting.

    After we receive your registration, a moderator will review it. After your registration is approved, you will be permitted to post.
    If you use a disposable or false email address, your registration will be rejected.

    After your membership is approved, please take a minute to tell us a little bit about yourself.
    https://www.radiodiscussions.com/forums/introduce-yourself.1088/

    Thanks in advance and have fun!
    RadioDiscussions Administrators

My Insignia HD radio bit the dust!

nd2023

Banned
I accidentally dropped my HD radio on the ground and now it won't pick up anything but the strongest signals. Resetting it or using different headphones didn't help.

Wonder if I should bother buying a new one.

For now, the HD2 stations in the New York market will have 10% less cume thanks to me.
 
Anybody figure out if there's a way you can tell by the 'date code' on the box (like 09a) that would signal a "new" and improved Insgnia HD radio or what? At least Radio Shack used to add an 'A' 'B' 'C' suffix to signal an improved (or de-proved) model (like moving production from Malaysia to China).

What advantages do the new HD units have, besides better battery life?? Do they still jump back to preset 1 when you push preset up? Still 4 point font size for RDS and station ID on RBDS stations that aren't HD? HD lock any better? Signal strength meter any more usefull?
 
JohnnyElectron said:
Anybody figure out if there's a way you can tell by the 'date code' on the box (like 09a) that would signal a "new" and improved Insgnia HD radio or what? At least Radio Shack used to add an 'A' 'B' 'C' suffix to signal an improved (or de-proved) model (like moving production from Malaysia to China).

What advantages do the new HD units have, besides better battery life?? Do they still jump back to preset 1 when you push preset up? Still 4 point font size for RDS and station ID on RBDS stations that aren't HD? HD lock any better? Signal strength meter any more usefull?

Well, based on some of this info, I hopped out to Best Buy and picked up a new one. Some notes:

- All portable radio type things are in the appliance section now.
- There's a date code at the lower left side of the back of the box that begins with "10", and it seems to be linked to the new generation radio. The sales guy at Best Buy (a.) knew where the HD radios were and (b.) opened the box to verify it was indeed the Version 4 firmware (specifically 4.00.14.)
- HD lock now happens FAST compared to the 1.0 firmware. Definitely an improvement.
- One thing that bugs me: the radio does much better when not connected to power. Wish that weren't the case.

I'll be commuting home with it attached to my car rig (aux cable draped over the rearview mirror, natch) and see if it drops out at all the old familiar places. (Hope I don't get fooled by tropo...)
 
I still shouldn't have to buy a new HD radio after less than a year. I have dropped my iPod many times and it still works perfectly. I have many analog radios that still work great after many years.
 
Nick said:
I still shouldn't have to buy a new HD radio after less than a year. I have dropped my iPod many times and it still works perfectly. I have many analog radios that still work great after many years.

That says more about the piss poor quality control and/or design of Insignia products than it does HD radio. My old radio was apparently defective right out of the box, as were a few others I tried from the same store.

I just posted a 'review' of a new unit I picked up with the 4.00.14 software. This new radio seems to perform like it should. The RDS feature is still wonky, but the reception is great. Finally.
 
So I bought a new Insignia HD radio from Best Buy. I'm sure iBiquity will love this additional sale, even though I bought it to replace a broken HD radio. To them, I am a customer who went to Best Buy exclusively to buy a new HD radio. I made sure to check that it was Version 4. New York HD2 stations will now have a major increase in their cume thanks to me :)

It performs better than my old one. HD decoded in a second with the call letters and locked in 3 seconds for a strong signal, and HD2s didn't drop out for as long as it did on the old one. When the HD reception dropped, it usually came back in a second. The RDS is very slow to decode however.

The annoying birdie at 107.9 is gone, and I find this unit to be more sensitive. It didn't overload standing across the street from a 100 watt station (on a 250 foot tower), and I could barely hear a first adjacent, which doesn't even come in on a car radio at that spot.

There was slight tropo from the approaching tropical storm, and I was able to hear bits and pieces of faraway stations.

My old HD radio isn't completely useless now, it still picks up very strong signals. Perhaps I could give it to a radio geek in Manhattan.

I'm sure the average person would not buy the same brand of radio after it breaks (or even buy a newer version of the same radio if their current one is working), but I'm a radio geek.

Of the reported 3 million HD radio sales so far, assume that 1 million of those radios are broken. Another million are sitting at radio stations prize cabinets, used to monitor PPM encoding or EAS, feed translators, or are used by station employees. 900,000 are in car manufacturing plants, yet to be installed, or are returned by drivers who are dissatisfied. 80,000 are in homes (primarily in iPod docking stations) or Zune HDs. 19,000 are gathering dust at homes. The remaining 1000 in daily use mostly belong to radio geeks.
 
I forgot one very important feature missing from my new Insignia: the ability to turn OFF HD decoding

Hopefully that "feature" is implemented in the next version.
 
Other features missing: sleep timer, AM band, stereo indicators on both AM & FM and in both modes (analog & digital) like Sangean added to the HD1X. I'm all for an external antenna jack too.
 
Nick said:
I'm sure the average person would not buy the same brand of radio after it breaks (or even buy a newer version of the same radio if their current one is working), but I'm a radio geek.

True. I'm a geek too since I did the exact same thing.

The truth of the matter is, though, if someone else offered a portable HD radio like this for a comparable price, I'd have tried it instead of buying another Insignia.
 
My Insignia's about done to, both rubber caps are gone from the headphones, and the last working bud gave out a few days ago. The screen is broken and theres a large crack in it. I'm trying to decide wheather to get a new one or just buy a new portable with SW and AM.
 
travisl5678 said:
My Insignia's about done to, both rubber caps are gone from the headphones, and the last working bud gave out a few days ago. The screen is broken and theres a large crack in it. I'm trying to decide wheather to get a new one or just buy a new portable with SW and AM.

Geez Travis, did you drop it into the garbage disposal with the rest of the leftovers?!? :D

I've dropped mine quite a few times, hit my wife in the eye with it once (a video of that escapade would be a winner on AFV!), have had to glue the top corner portions back on, yet it still works as well as ever. Now that I purchased a newer one, the original has been relegated to serving me while I do things like mowing the lawn or other forms of manual labor. It still hangs in there - can't complain about the build quality of it...it's been pretty rugged.
 
BRNout said:
travisl5678 said:
My Insignia's about done to, both rubber caps are gone from the headphones, and the last working bud gave out a few days ago. The screen is broken and theres a large crack in it. I'm trying to decide wheather to get a new one or just buy a new portable with SW and AM.

Geez Travis, did you drop it into the garbage disposal with the rest of the leftovers?!? :D
Just about :D

The screen crack and the broken screen (It just shows a few yellow blobs on the screen) Came from me putting it in my back pocket and sitting on it. It would still work once I get some new headphones (Barely, the headphones are the antenna)
 
Two questions:

a) Has anyone figured out if it's possible to take the Insignia portable apart to look at the insides? (And please don't answer “with a hammer” because I'd like to put it back together afterwards, lol.)

2) Has anyone tried the other cheapo-deepo brand of HD radio, the Coby? Saw it on their website the other day. I think it's retailing for $60. It's a cube with a speaker, with built-in telescoping FM antenna and jacks for AM. It didn't specify specifically that it decoded AM HD. In the specs said "Stereo AM/FM Radio" which is also curious. The brand being a Wal-Mart special doesn't give me high hopes, but it might be a clunky alternative to the Insignia lineup.
 
Perhaps since people aren't buying these radios, they're making them so they last a year so that people like us keep buying a new one every year, boosting their sales figures and iBiquity's claims of more HD radios sold. I'm sure they also count a returned radio that is re-sold to someone else as 2 separate sales.
 
Status
This thread has been closed due to inactivity. You can create a new thread to discuss this topic.


Back
Top Bottom