I never implied that Seattle is incredibly unique, although there was a former RD member here who once insisted that Seattle is a unique audience and consultants from other regions don't understand it and are destined to fail.Sure, that's the way it's done. Advertisers want to reach an demographic, so stations do programming that (they hope) will attract that audience.
Again, that's the way it's done.
That's any business relationship. You earn your pay doing the best job possible. Do a bad job, and you don't do business.
That amounts to a wives tail. This whole fallacy that Seattle/Tacoma is some mystical-snowflake-media-wonderland, is completely bogus. Was Seattle different than say LA back in the 60's through 80's before there was as much audience research? Maybe, but having worked with TV and radio consultants all over the U.S., I can tell you that all listeners/viewers want is high quality programming. Sure, there are subtle nuances between formats/markets due to demo/geographic and socioeconomic reasons, but this whole 'Seattle is SO unique' that consultants don't know what they're doing, is bunk.
This is broadcasting. You're trying to reach a broad audience. Are there a smattering of people who don't like whichever station for whatever reason? Of course. One needs to just surf this very site to see outliers. Does that mean because a handful of people who laugh at whatever format are the majority? Nope.
I don't share that guy's opinion.
That said, they could at least get it right. Some advertisers have, in the past. There was a long running sequence of radio spots by a company that included Seattle-typical characters like Latte lady and sandals and socks guy -- they were humorous, and caught the ear, because they were accurate caricatures and stereotypes. And they were commercials put out by an ad agency that obviously had done some research. They got it right. The "PNW" promos attempt to get it right, and fail.
Will it kill the station? I doubt it. Many listeners may not notice. Many of them are transplants, probably. Seattle is full of transplants, especially within the city limits.
But imaging, and how it is delivered, is important. If it weren't, stations wouldn't spend so much time and money on it. After all, the music is already available on Spotify, Pandora and YT. But a radio station offers a little more than background music of your favorite genre of format. Otherwise, the consultants and owners of KPNW wouldn't have bothered with imaging and format tweaks to reach a specific demographic. They'd just play the music and the millions of listeners would come.
But from everything I've read here on RD over the decade I've been here, that isn't how it works. Although the music mix hooks the listeners, the imaging and presentation still mean something.