• Get involved.
    We want your input!
    Apply for Membership and join the conversations about everything related to broadcasting.

    After we receive your registration, a moderator will review it. After your registration is approved, you will be permitted to post.
    If you use a disposable or false email address, your registration will be rejected.

    After your membership is approved, please take a minute to tell us a little bit about yourself.
    https://www.radiodiscussions.com/forums/introduce-yourself.1088/

    Thanks in advance and have fun!
    RadioDiscussions Administrators

NYC Metro Radio Ratings - December 2022

Which formats exist in New York, that are not available in other large cities? The only one I can think of is WBAI, which only has sister stations in a few other places.

It's rare to have a full-time jazz station in a city. New York has two if you count WKCR with WBGO. The diversity in ethnic programming doesn't exist in other big cities. Some places, such as Philadelphia, are just now getting their first full signal FM Hispanic station, while New York has several. The complaints people have about radio are a function of the market demographics. There are rock and country stations in the suburbs, where the majority of the population wants that kind of programming. You don't have as many people looking for rock and country in the five boroughs. That's just a fact.

The fact that NY has two all-news stations and so many people here advocate both of them having FM simulcasts seems crazy to me. If the city lacks format diversity, why would anyone want four all-news stations? Makes no sense to me, other than the posters don't like WXBK.

To use Atlanta as an example, they have the same major formats as New York, plus plenty of ethnic programming, urban music stations, jazz on non-commercial stations, Alt, and several Country stations.

Atlanta doesn't have a classic hits station like WCBS-FM. The River is a classic rock station, more like WAXQ. Atlanta doesn't have ONE all news station, much less two. Atlanta used to have a non-commercial modern rock station, WRAS, that is now a duplicate NPR station. Until recently, their rock station was a dog. But once again, the diversity of the radio stations reflect the diversity of the population. Cities are becoming more black and Hispanic. That's a sociological fact. That will affect the radio stations.
 
Last edited:
Why does WNYM (Hackensack) never show up in the NY ratings?, I know they have many listeners.
They are not subscribed. Non-subscribed stations don't show up in the free ratings reports issued by Nielsen.
 
Would that happen to be my local market, Knoxville, TN? Other than the plethora of Country choices here, the NYC dial has much better variety than we have in Knoxville.
I was actually thinking Rochester, NY, but that example could be applied to a number of other markets I'm sure.
 
Last edited:
They are not subscribed. Non-subscribed stations don't show up in the free ratings reports issued by Nielsen.
Does the same apply for WNTP (990) in Philadelphia Dave? because I never see them in the ratings either, and they're popular also.
 
We lack Alternative Rock and Country stations. With several stations playing the same types of music aka KTU, Z, and 102.7 and Lite. BLS, Hot, Power, and The Block, 97.9, 93.1, and 96.3 and spoken word The Fan and ESPN radio we lack variety 100%. With 92.3 being all news and 98.7 and 101.9 being sports when they're on AM, theres waste of space. Non commercial stations being 92.7, 95.5, 96.7 and soon to be 103.9 we are losing valuable radio frequencies.
Alternative and Country failed in New York City in both ratings and revenue. Regardless of the operator, you would have seen the same result. To say that there is a lack of variety because two formats that were not successful when they WERE offered (in multiple iterations) is an asinine statement.

David already explained why there is musical overlap amongst stations, and yet you keep saying the same thing over and over. And may I remind you that the majority of the stations you list are all successful in multiple ways, not just ratings. If they weren't, maybe I'd agree with you.

And an FM frequency is only valuable if there is something valuable on it. One would argue that 92.7, 95.5, and 103.9 were not running valuable programming.
 
Alternative and Country failed in New York City in both ratings and revenue. Regardless of the operator, you would have seen the same result. To say that there is a lack of variety because two formats that were not successful when they WERE offered (in multiple iterations) is an asinine statement.

David already explained why there is musical overlap amongst stations, and yet you keep saying the same thing over and over. And may I remind you that the majority of the stations you list are all successful in multiple ways, not just ratings. If they weren't, maybe I'd agree with you.

And an FM frequency is only valuable if there is something valuable on it. One would argue that 92.7, 95.5, and 103.9 were not running valuable programming.
Only 95.5 is a city frequency, 103.9 is White Plains and 92.7 not sure but 92.3 is in the city, next frequency up would be 93.1
 
We lack Alternative Rock and Country stations. With several stations playing the same types of music aka KTU, Z, and 102.7 and Lite. BLS, Hot, Power, and The Block, 97.9, 93.1, and 96.3 and spoken word The Fan and ESPN radio we lack variety 100%. With 92.3 being all news and 98.7 and 101.9 being sports when they're on AM, theres waste of space. Non commercial stations being 92.7, 95.5, 96.7 and soon to be 103.9 we are losing valuable radio frequencies.
Using one format area, you say that WBLS, Hot, Power and The Block are "the same". In fact, they are very different.

One is Urban AC, a format generally appealing to Blacks over age 30. Another is Urban, appealing primarily to Blacks but also Hispanics mostly under 45. Then there is one that is Churban, and it appeals to under-40 persons who are non-Hispanic white, Black and Hispanic. And another is classic hip hop, rap and urban and appeals first to Hispanics and then Blacks in the 30-49 age range.

Similarly, you describe WKTU and Z-100 as being "the same" and they are not!

Whether a station is non-commercial or not does not make any difference. And non-coms can often sustain formats and approaches that commercial radio can't serve due to the requirements of advertisers.

And there is the magic word: advertisers. Commercial radio can only exist by giving advertisers a useful medium by which to send messages to consumers.

Alternative and country have been amply found to be ineffective in attracting advertisers due to small and less sought-after audiences. That is not a "radio" problem... it is an issue with the companies that buy radio advertising.
 
Which formats exist in New York, that are not available in other large cities? The only one I can think of is WBAI, which only has sister stations in a few other places.
The Mega format and the Amor formats are principally focused on Dominicans, and, since there is no really sizable Dominican community anywhere else, we could say both of those SBS stations are not available elsewhere in the USA..
 
I agree that the music mix on Amor is rather unique. I haven't even been able to find something similar online.
But to me, Mega sounds about the same as WXNY 96.3, Caliente on SiriusXM, and other Hispanic CHR stations.
Just curious-Since the sizable local Mexican population no longer has a station focusing on it, does a significant portion listen to Amor?
 
Last edited:
@AceBicuits
I recall seeing a Harrisburg PA book once, in which some 5 or 6 Country stations made the 12+ book. Perhaps you mean them ; this unlikely #84 market?
It was long enough ago that I don't recall the letters, except for the now-dark WWSM 1510, a daylighter.
 
I agree that the music mix on Amor is rather unique. I haven't even been able to find something similar online.
But to me, Mega sounds about the same as WXNY 96.3, Caliente on SiriusXM, and other Hispanic CHR stations.
There is a big focus on both Dominican recording artists as well as Dominican on-air staff.
Just curious-Since the sizable local Mexican population no longer has a station focusing on it, does a significant portion listen to Amor?
The highly Dominican music content has very limited to zero appeal among Mexicans. Totally different tastes, cultures and ethnicities.
 
I was actually thinking Rochester, NY, but that example could be applied to a number of other markets I'm sure.
There are only two country stations in the core of the Rochester market, the dominant WBEE and iHeart's WDVI, which has only had the format for a year and hasn't made a significant ratings dent.

Sure, you can hear WLKK in most of Monroe County, but it's a Buffalo market station, and WCJW and WUUF are relatively distant rimshots without viable Monroe County signals.
 
@AceBicuits
I recall seeing a Harrisburg PA book once, in which some 5 or 6 Country stations made the 12+ book. Perhaps you mean them ; this unlikely #84 market?
Four country stations made the last book in #221 Hanover/Lebanon/White River Jct NH/VT, and all were over 2.0 last book (3.4, 3.4, 2.7, 2.1). Only 162,000 people in the MSA.

Note: A couple of out-of-market country stations also showed up in the last book, but both only appear occasionally and usually with not much more than "participation trophy" bogus 0.1s.
 
Last edited:
Does at least one of those Country stations play classic Country and/or lots of 90's songs?? That would be a rather different sound from a contemporary Country station.
 
Does at least one of those Country stations play classic Country and/or lots of 90's songs?? That would be a rather different sound from a contemporary Country station.
Three are contemporary, with plenty of recurrents and recent gold. One, the lowest rated, is primarily classic country ('80s/'90s centered, but even a few Patsy Cline and Hank Sr. songs!), three or four currents per hour, and two vaguely country pop oldies ("Lodi," "Teach Your Children," "Carolina in My Mind," for example) per hour.
 
Status
This thread has been closed due to inactivity. You can create a new thread to discuss this topic.


Back
Top Bottom