A rule of thumb or two, which might have an effect in your West Milford listening and your Dad's, Pirate Jim.
The Palisades are pretty well up there and right smack in the way. There are some spots even around North Bergen where you drive along the Hudson and swear you're looking down at the Empire State Building.
And virtually all of the AMers (should someone be interested in 620, 930, 970, 1330, et al) plow their signals in the opposite direction from West Milford.
I've been through there a few times as a kid. One of the loveliest places in the area. But after having DXed from there, and from Kerhonkson, Rosendale and Woodboune in the Catskills along that arc of stalagmites, I'm reminded of a pal's gleeful words when a few of us were trying to receive anything on the radio : 'What a great spot to DX! Nothing comes in!'