Yes, some of the Part 15 FM modulators on the new HD radio receivers (intended to re-transmit the received signal to an existing analog FM car radio) have ranges up to 1/4 mile, which is *far* greater than the range of a Part 15 compliant FM transmitter!
However, the Talking House, TalkingSign, and AM1000 Rangemaster Part 15 AM transmitters have been around for many years and are in widespread use. If they were "out of spec" with regard to the Part 15 AM rules, their manufacturers would have long ago been cited by the FCC. (Ramsey has been raided by the FCC at least once, although the raid(s) was/were in connection with their non-compliant Part 15 FM transmitters rather than their Part 15 AM transmitters.)
-- Black Shire
However, the Talking House, TalkingSign, and AM1000 Rangemaster Part 15 AM transmitters have been around for many years and are in widespread use. If they were "out of spec" with regard to the Part 15 AM rules, their manufacturers would have long ago been cited by the FCC. (Ramsey has been raided by the FCC at least once, although the raid(s) was/were in connection with their non-compliant Part 15 FM transmitters rather than their Part 15 AM transmitters.)
-- Black Shire
desert_er said:One thing to keep in mind here is that the interpretation of the part 15 rules is up to the individual field inspector. The violation referenced in the earlier post was regarding an installation with *100'* of ground-lead wire. I'm sure it was apparent to the inspector that this installation was purposefully in violation of the rules. Who's to say if the same inspector would've scrutinized a residential rooftop installation with a 15' lead directly to ground? According to the Hamilton site, such installations have indeed passed an inspection and remained in operation without changes.
Do FCC rules trump the NEC? That really isnt a valid question, considering that it would still be possible to follow code by relocating the transmitter to ground level, or say, using a 1m ground lead, and a 2m antenna. Following the rules of these two regulating bodies is an "and" situation rather than an "or". Both should be taken into consideration for a given installation.
Just because a device is part 15 accepted (i.e. "real-estate" transmitters) doesn't necessarily mean that it is operating within the limits. Read the article in BERadio regarding "part 15" devices on the FM band... Most of them radiate way more than they are "supposed" to. Guess the FCC certification office needs to tighten the slack a bit. NPR is reeling over this, since most part 15 FM transmitters are in the NCE part of the band.
Part 15 transmitters cannot defy the laws of physics. Period. Certainly it can be difficult to calculate the real-world performance of these installations due the the infinite number of variables involved. I was thinkking of this thread earlier this week as I was using an HP signal generator to tune an ATU for an AM facility that I was moving. The generator put *out* 25mW, and the calculated efficiency of the feedline/ATU/ground system/soil conductivity/.225-wave tower was about 76%. This is still more than 10dB higer than a 'ground mounted' part 15. Modulated with 1000Hz tone, I took a drive and set the GPS on the dash. Signal was clear/listenable to about 1km, noisy/somewhat listenable by 2-2.5km, and by 3-3.5km was just barely perceptible or non-existent. I was able to go out to 4km in three directions, and even with the car off was unable to detect the presence of any signal.