Barry Young should be somewhere on the top, AND should also have a longer show time, in addition to weekend time.
My top picks would be
1. Coast To Coast AM with George Noory
2. The Nearly Famous Barry Young
3. Handel on The Law
4. ...well I'm not exactly sure what 4 is and don't want to spend any time thinking about it or coming back to edit, but I'll just say Mike Broomhead is very good too, and The Tech Guy Leo Laporte I got used to because he would come on my Sunday line up of favorite shows, when I used to use Sunday's to "unwind" and listen to certain shows from around noon til' Coast. I remember when the Rusty Humphrey show was one of my favorites, but now it's been so long that I'm not sure if I can accurately say he's still one of my favorites today, since I've changed a bit and also changed my ways of thinking and how I process information I'm given since that time. Rusty Humphrey was actually the one who introduced me to common sense and taught me that what feels good or sounds good isn't always the most sensible and logical decision to make, and there are SOME (not all) times when emotion should be the bases of your decision making and opinions.... but unfortunately there are still too many people in this world who can't see or detect this... but that's another story I will not even spend the next few hours getting into right now. ... Look at me already starting! I probably need my own show... alright - ENOUGH SAID.
BOTTOM LINE IS THIS:
I wish Coast to Coast and Barry Young were on FM, and those would be my picks for the best. I'm sure other cities and towns have people I haven't even heard of that are good, too. Rush always hits me with common sense issues, facts, and logical thinking, but there's just something about his show that doesn't keep me tuned in. Barry just has that voice and attitude, and most of the Coast to Coast AM hosts have that perfect sound for that type of show.