Julius Was Right
Friday afternoon and evening I listened to XM Radio's (60s on Six) five hour tribute/recreation of the great Top 40 station CKLW (Windsor, Detroit, Toledo) and then heard the Jim Nettleton WFIL aircheck which were streamed before the Radio Racket program.
The difference was striking and confirms what Julius and others have been saying all along about Philadelphia radio. As it was in the beginning, is now and ever shall be: Philadelphia radio is dull, copy-cat, low energy and uninspiring. CKLW, The Big 8, had movement, passion, creativity, drive, originality: all the things Philadelphia's Top 40 stations lacked. WIBG and WFIL by comparison had good voices, good production but no heart, no soul and nothing really to distinguish them from a hundred others.
Everybody feels a certain emotional tug for the station and the music "you grew up with." Hometown pride is understandable. But Philadelphia radio was short-changing its listeners even then.
XM Radio salutes a different Top 40 station each Friday (4pm to 9pm). But few were ever as great as CKLW, or the other legendary Detroit Top 40 stations, 12-70 WXYZ, Radio 15 WJBK, and WKNR Keener 13. Besides Top 40 and into the 70s, Detroit also had as its number station WJR, a station with live booth announcers, a station orchestra and male and female vocalists doing daily live shows, a daily documentary series, a daily instructional program in classical music, and a live talk/interview show with a studio audience. Before Top 40 radio, one Detroit station also gave the US The Green Hornet, Sergeant Preston and The Lone Ranger. In some radio markets the magic happens. In others, it doesn't.