The Voice of Reason said:
Matt Smith said:
Andy should have stayed in Mayberry. If he had done so, that show likely would have survived CBS's "Rural Purge" that was the death knell to TAGS successor "Mayberry RFD."
Griffith wanted to move on to other projects which is the reason he decided to call it quits. Besides eight years is a long time for a series any ways. Also consider that without Don Knotts, the Andy Griffith Show was never the same. Jack Burns, Jack Dodson and a host of other replacements were never as good as the original cast
As for staying on and surviving the CBS purge of rural shows, perhaps his show might have survived. However there were other high-rated shows that were expunged during the "Rural Purge" and it is very likely that Griffith's show might have been one of them. IMHO "The Andy Griffith Show" despite its popularity in today's reruns, wasn't the same show in 1968 as it was in 1960-61.
'Mayberry RFD' was declining, but still hanging on in the top 20, when CBS cancelled it. They might have been able to squeeze at least a couple more seasons out of it, especially if they'd left it on Mondays with 'Gunsmoke' as its lead-in.
Perhaps the loss of a half-hour of prime-time due to the access rule in 1971 had more to do with 'RFD's cancellation than the 'rural purge' did?The curious thing about CBS dropping all those 'hicks and older folks' shows in '70 and '71, was that they didn't kill 'My Three Sons' at that point.
Instead, 'Mayberry RFD' got the axe, and CBS made an unusual move of scheduling two sitcoms back-to-back at 10 ET..'My Three Sons' and 'Arnie'...apparently just so they could finally kill the Douglas family for good. But why go to the trouble of picking it up at all? If 'Mayberry' could die maybe a year too soon, why not 'Sons'?
'My Three Sons' preceded the first season of 'Mary Tyler Moore' on Saturdays at 9 ET in '70-71, and actually outrated MTM that year.
For 1971, CBS plugged 'The New Dick Van Dyke Show' into that slot. thinking his lead-in would help Mary. Instead, Mary had much better ratings in year two, ranking ahead of DVD, and CBS eventually moved and revamped his show, which only lasted 3 years.
Presumably 'My Three Sons' might have at least held on in top 30 if it had stayed on Saturdays for season 12. Otherwise, keeping it on just to move it to a 'death timeslot' didn't make much sense.