Rolling In The Deep vs. All I Wanna Do

[tflo]

Compare multi-format charting of "Rolling In The Deep" // "All I Wanna Do", do any other songs come close? Corrections/additions welcome; (chart peaks of each in parenthesis)

Hot 100 (1//2)

Top 40 mainstream (3//1)
Top 40 rhythmic (28 [to date]//31)

Adult Top 40 (1//no chart published)
Adult Contemporary (8//1)

Modern Rock (21//4)
Mainstream Rock (--/35)
Rock Songs (15/--)
Triple A (1//??)

Dance/Club Play (14//??)

 

[ThatGuyOnTheRadio]

Since when is "Adult Top 40" a recognized charted format?

 

[AM FM listener]

Since when is "Adult Top 40" a recognized charted format?

I think that is Billboard's name for Hot AC.

 

[HotAC Guru]

On the Radio and Records' Hot AC chart, "All I Wanna Do" spent 6 weeks at #1.

 

[tflo]

On the Radio and Records' Hot AC chart, "All I Wanna Do" spent 6 weeks at #1.

yes, thank you...just noticed that in http://www.popradiotop20.com/1/index.htm

 

[atlantaboy]

Compare multi-format charting of "Rolling In The Deep" // "All I Wanna Do", do any other songs come close?

Use Somebody by Kings Of Leon charted on CHR, Hot AC, AC, AAA, Alternative, Active Rock, and Mainstream Rock

We Belong Together by Mariah Carey charted on CHR, Hot AC, AC, Rhythmic, Urban, Urban AC, and Smooth Jazz

 

[AM FM listener]

The thing is that many of these charts are overlapping, such as the various rock and r&b charts, so it is not all that surprising to see songs chart on several of them and then cross over to one of the pop charts.

Even more impressive would be a song charting on one of the rock charts and one of the urban charts since they rarely overlap. Perhaps Eminem or Beastie Boys?

 

[atlantaboy]

The thing is that many of these charts are overlapping, such as the various rock and r&b charts

???

No they're not - all the format charts listed above are separate formats, each with their own separate panel of stations

I think Billboard has some composite charts, but all the formats mentioned above are separate Mediabase formats

 

[Slinky]

Use Somebody by Kings Of Leon charted on CHR, Hot AC, AC, AAA, Alternative, Active Rock, and Mainstream Rock

We Belong Together by Mariah Carey charted on CHR, Hot AC, AC, Rhythmic, Urban, Urban AC, and Smooth Jazz

To me, "All I Wanna Do" and "Rolling In The Deep" are more impressive because they both charted AAA and Rhythmic. That's a rare feat! Those formats are about as polar opposite as you can get.

You can say Eminem broke down the barriers for charting both Alternative and Rhythmic, but AAA and Rhythmic have gone years without any songs in common.

 

[AM FM listener]

The thing is that many of these charts are overlapping, such as the various rock and r&b charts

???

No they're not - all the format charts listed above are separate formats, each with their own separate panel of stations

I think Billboard has some composite charts, but all the formats mentioned above are separate Mediabase formats

I understand what you are saying but what I meant was the music on Active Rock, Mainstream Rock and Alternative are overlapping. It is not surprising when a song makes all three of those charts. It is more surprising when a song makes one of those rock charts AND one or more of the Rhythm-oriented charts (Rhythmic, Urban, Urban AC).

 

[William_Yeager]

Compare multi-format charting of "Rolling In The Deep" // "All I Wanna Do", do any other songs come close?

Use Somebody by Kings Of Leon charted on CHR, Hot AC, AC, AAA, Alternative, Active Rock, and Mainstream Rock

We Belong Together by Mariah Carey charted on CHR, Hot AC, AC, Rhythmic, Urban, Urban AC, and Smooth Jazz

Lifehouse's "Hanging By A Moment" put up a similar performance to "Use Somebody", although I don't recall it charting at AC-what was scary was how close it came well after the song had run its course at other formats. Lifehouse actually came close to putting a mirror image run on Christian Radio as well, but not enough Christian CHR and Christian Rock stations were playing it at the same time for it to chart. The song actually came closer to charting at Christian AC than mainstream AC, but failed there as well.