CTListener said:
Proselytizing is part and parcel of Christianity for the denominations that run radio ministries. I don't think the FCC or any other government branch can do anything about those radio station deals on the grounds that Christian evangelism isn't in the best interest of a given community.
It doesn't serve the community of license - or even the metro area of license. Furthermore, the airwaves are (supposedly) publicly-owned and licenses to use them are allocated by the FCC. I find it interesting that we have athiestic zealots filing lawsuits over things like Christmas trees on public property, yet they don't seem to worry when religious broadcasters are buying up the airwaves left and right. Not to mention that far too many of these stations seem to be more about bilking the gullible out of their hard-earned cash as they are about proselytizing the uninitiated.
Let's take a quick look at Canada, where such formats are not banned but are controlled so that they are not overrepresented on the dial. Granted, Canada's system overreaches far too much - but the point is that it can be done. When reviewing for new licenses, the format and it's service to the COL is taken into account. Canada does have religious broadcasters, but very few. Basically in line with the size of the audience.
In some places in the US, these stations are far too prevalent on the dial. Right now, I'm thinking of central New York where there are far too many of these stations and where there are too few commercial stations. Wild comment: personally, I'd prefer to see licenses turned in than bandwidth taken up by powerhouses that no one listens to. All they do is block the out of market signals that may well do a better job in serving the people of that listening area.
The case of WCYI is a great example to consider. Maine is hardly a hotbed of born-again Christianity. It's just not, so I don't even want to get into that argument. And, there already is WBCI which is a religious broadcaster that managed to snag a powerhouse signal. OK, fine, we have one FM religious station in the area. Based on the various ratings books, almost no one listens to it but it is there and doing its thing. It serves the very few who do appreciate that type of broadcasting. But, the people of that area DO NOT need another such station. Here is where I wish a line could be drawn.
The whole thing has gotten out of hand and if it continues apace, rural areas will basically be stuck with a bunch of K-Love and snake handler stations (live from Twin Falls, Idaho) on translators, plus one local country station and maybe a rocker. And that is not how the spectrum should be doled out. I'm all for the free market, but even that great concept needs guidance at times.