I'll buy that about Scott's prep work.
Unfortunately, I think one of the problems when I've listened to him (at least when he was doing sports talk) was that he was TOO scripted!
He'd do the opening commentary, and it was always well written.
I still remember a lot of them- his first one on sneaking to listen to the 1969 World Series on the radio, catching Myron Cope on the radio driving back from Maryland and relishing the phrase "Hit that guy with a polish sausage!" (and for you real Steelers fans- you know EXACTLY who Myron was talking about and the situation eight years later in large part because of this commentary), uncovering the feats of forgotten Pirates pitcher Heinie Meine.
Unfortunately, I noticed something about these commentaries. THEY WERE LONG!
And I mean dreadfully long. I mean the show began at 3 p.m. and he's still on the commentary/essay/lecture at 3:20 p.m.
I'm talking about a commentary that was longer than my actual car trip.
It was nearly impossible to follow the commentary it was so long! Iron Butterfly had songs shorter than some of these monologues! You just wanted him to get to the point!
Still, at the end of the day, I'm a Paulsen fan and I'm disapointed he won't be co-hosting the show with Steigy.
Because it speaks well of a guy's professionalism when the worst thing you can say about him is "He was TOO prepared!"