• Get involved.
    We want your input!
    Apply for Membership and join the conversations about everything related to broadcasting.

    After we receive your registration, a moderator will review it. After your registration is approved, you will be permitted to post.
    If you use a disposable or false email address, your registration will be rejected.

    After your membership is approved, please take a minute to tell us a little bit about yourself.
    https://www.radiodiscussions.com/forums/introduce-yourself.1088/

    Thanks in advance and have fun!
    RadioDiscussions Administrators

Severe Weather Warnings - Poorly Done in Philly

This summer has featured a number of days with severe thunderstorms, when the NWS has issued severe thunderstorm warnings and other advisories. For example, last night featured Severe Thunderstorm Warnings for portions of Chester, Delaware and New Castle Counties. Yet, almost every Philly station snoozed through the entire event!

Aside from a quick crawl (block white letters - very old fashioned) on Fox 29 - very little notice was given to the severe weather during prime time. Sure, it was covered on the 11:00 news - but that was after the action was over. I have noticed this handling of severe weather since moving here and it really surprises me. Aside from WFMZ, not ONE other station has a continuous on-screen warning about potentially dangerous weather! Ever. It's ironic that the station with the lowest budget does the best job in this regard.

In almost every other market, most network stations superimpose a little map notifying the viewer of the advisories. Some stations even alternate that map with a small view of doppler radar. And, no, this doesn't just happen in tornado alley. You see it done in New England, in the west, pretty much everywhere. It has become the standard. In fact, many stations go so far as to do it for severe t-storm watches, flash flood watches, winter weather advisories and pretty much anything else that the NWS comes out with.

Why are Philadelphia area stations so poor about this? Not one station can post a severe T-storm map? Do they all think that it's still 1975 (as ch. 6 does)? It is unbelievable to me. I'd be really interested to learn why this is. Seems to me that they're being lazy.

We are forecast to have a significant outbreak of severe weather this evening. From what I can tell, the public needs to have weather radios at the ready because the local stations seem to be very deficient when it comes to disseminating weather warnings (WFMZ-69 excepted). Ironically, these are the same stations that absolutely freak out if an inch of snow is on the way! Very strange indeed.
 
Ironic that when I lived in DC the folks complained about too MUCH storm coverage! God forbid they cover a possible tornado and you have to interrupt America Idol or Oprah to do it! Especially if the storm is not near your location!

So yes, if in fact if you really want the best warning you do indeed need a weather radio and I suggest one with S.A.M.E technology. Or Specific Area Message Encryption. This way, weather watching TV or not you get the actual NWS warning. With S.A.M.E you put in your own county code and are then warned only if for example you live in Chester and the not the ones issued for say, Burlington Co in NJ.
 
On Wednesday, I saw maps with the warning areas on both 10 and 6. The scrolls run twice in most cases that I've seen, with a tone preceding them. That's plenty of warning for a thunderstorm system.
 
imhomerjay said:
On Wednesday, I saw maps with the warning areas on both 10 and 6. The scrolls run twice in most cases that I've seen, with a tone preceding them. That's plenty of warning for a thunderstorm system.

No, it isn't. In most markets, the map stays up as long as the warnings are still in force. We were under a Severe T'storm Warning in Chester County and I checked around the dial repeatedly - no maps and no crawl. Nor have I ever caught one in my year of living here (except on WFMZ).

Perhaps they do a quick crawl, as all stations used to do back in the 70's - but leaving up a small map in the corner of the screen is the standard nowadays. Remember, the idea is to inform the uninformed (i.e. the folks who rarely tune in the Weather Channel).
 
One word describes TV weather...DISGRACE
Thursday night ch.29's promo threatened power outtages, severe wind and rain. Not long after here comes what they laughingly call news. All of a sudden..no storms, just showers. No lightning, no wind, no heavy rain. As far as I'm concerend that just out and out lying. When will viewers stop putting up with this crap? A few minutes online will get you whatever forecast you need. Those without internet, KYW radio gives a good, quick summary.
I don't know how many times Glenn "I get it right" Schwartz and laughing boy on Ch.6 say the rain is gone. So why is it raining in my neighborhood?
 
For those like me (weather geek and former radio employee) we long ago turned away from TV weather except for the 'eye candy'!
I use www.wunderground.com here the forecast discussion from the NWS is translated from 'geek speak' to regular english.
http://www.wunderground.com/DisplayDisc.asp?DiscussionCode=PHI&StateCode=PA&SafeCityName=Glenmoore

In fact many times you can hear the TV heads have read this and are basing their forecasts from it anyway.

The radars can also be zoomed rather nicely.
In winter during the current 'blizzard of the century' the NWS updates the info frequently and even after they (NWS) have downgraded a storm, the talking heads are still touting snow snow snow!

Also I was serious about getting the weather radio with S.A.M.E. I lived near LaPlata Md in April 2002 when the F4 came through, see http://www.erh.noaa.gov/er/lwx/Historic_Events/apr28-2002/laplata.htm.
Radio was invaluable then and I gave them as gifts the next Christmas!

www.saitta-weather.com
 
cyber said:
One word describes TV weather...DISGRACE
Thursday night ch.29's promo threatened power outtages, severe wind and rain. Not long after here comes what they laughingly call news. All of a sudden..no storms, just showers. No lightning, no wind, no heavy rain. As far as I'm concerend that just out and out lying. When will viewers stop putting up with this crap? A few minutes online will get you whatever forecast you need. Those without internet, KYW radio gives a good, quick summary.
I don't know how many times Glenn "I get it right" Schwartz and laughing boy on Ch.6 say the rain is gone. So why is it raining in my neighborhood?

Of course, let's play the flip side--had they not mentioned the possibility of that kind of damaging storm and it happened, someone would be on hear blasting them for not raising the possibility of a bad storm.

Lying? No. Weather forecasting isn't an exact science, and the conditions were such that the possibility of those kinds of storms existed. So it didn't happen--better that outcome than the alternative.

And I for one don't need a map blocking my view of the program more than during the initial warning. If you're a huge weather nut, turn on the weather channel.
 
It's my understanding that by the time that promo aired the severe storm watch had been called off. If those idiots are too lazy to get off their incompetent asses and update their promos they should find another business to go into where credibility doesn't matter. Yes I'm sick and tired of the total crap that passes for news etc. Don Henley's "Dirty Laundry" is tame compared to the trash junking up the airways. I also blame viewers for turning this garbage on in the first place. For years I've just surfed through and stopped now and then. I shouldn't even do that but sometimes the word amateur is too high a standard and I have to stop and stare with disbelief at the train wreck that infects all area stations.
btw:I'm not a disgruntled former TV employee nor did I ever wish to get into TV.
 
I would have to disagree with the above posters and say that the warnings are a bit OVERdone. That beeping tone that channel 6 uses is very annoying. I keep thinking that its someone that cursed getting beeped out. They can scroll a warning across the bottom of the screen without the stupid tone. It goes right through me and drives my cat up the wall!
 
Status
This thread has been closed due to inactivity. You can create a new thread to discuss this topic.


Back
Top Bottom