For what it’s worth (free = nothing on this board), I agree with Bob’s prognosis (particularly concerning the Fox in other dayparts)—but not with his prescription for what ails ’CMF.
Dave Kane, a midday institution, should stay right where he is. And, nothing personal (I’ve never met him), but Robinson should go—but not to mornings. (I’ve never been a fan of the sophomoric, way-too-long phoners. VoxPro, or whatever you now use, is great for editing phone calls—use it!)
Both stations, however, must deal with this: Classic rock as a format is stale and boring. Whatever happened to good old-fashioned AOR, where a station mixed true classics (songs like “Layla”) with newer mainstream rock? Airing songs by “new-ish” bands such as Coldplay, Linkin Park, 3 Doors Down and many others would give overplayed Boston and Led Zeppelin much-needed rests.
Who remembers the days back when ’CMF mixed in the Human League and Soft Cell with AC/DC, Genesis, Journey, REO, Rush, Skynyrd, the Stones and the Who? At the very least, it made AOR—and radio, in general—more vibrant and exciting.