It's kind of like how many stations jumped the shark when the first PPM results came out and WRONGLY concluded oldies was a dead/dying format. It was ANYTHING but dying (maybe freakishly adrift sometimes, but certainly not dead/dying by any means.....)
With that first knowledge, they tried to reason that Boomers were an obsolete generation to music radio.
Fact: They're it's most dedicated listeners.
Most younger folks have their iPods and online sources. Most average teens/twentysomethings don't even LIKE terrestrial radio because it's something they cannot directly control.
To them, radio is just that thing in the car when the MP3/CD player doesn't work. Or that their parents put up with that doesn't play uncensored rap/rock and talks too much. Or has music they hear too much of/has music too old for them to relate to.
Arbitron may say terrestrial radio listening is bigger than ever with younger listeners. Not from what I see around me wherever I go. But then again, it's Arbitron. What are they supposed to say to the industry that they most notably exist on and it's increasingly finicky advertisers? FEWER young people are listening?
Older people who grew up with radio are far more patient than today's commercial pop music fan. Again, the younger folks have far more control over what they hear digitally than anything terrestrial or even satellite radio can offer. Even though "Pumped Up Kicks" or "Party Rock Anthem" will be coming on anywhere in 3....2....1, they want it NOW. And they aren't going to be patient. It's 2012. They have no need to be.
And Smooth Jazz has a VERY loyal hard core of fans. It's not HUGE, but it's there. And in any given market.
But when the industry started sweeping the Smooth Jazz stations off en masse, they lost a LOT of once-devoted-to-radio Boomers. Who resigned to their suspicions that terrestrial radio had completely gone to hell and signed up for XM/Sirius or tuning in via land or mobile web to the plentiful options via the internet.
Neither the recession or the corporate radio mindset was going to force them to put up with something they didn't want to hear.
And once you've lost them this way and took them enough out of their beloved comfort zone of traditional radio to make them have to pay for and learn the ways of New Radio, you've probably lost them forever. And an afterthought nighttime show on a crappy AM signal is really an insult to their intelligence. Ante up please. They've been fooled with enough.
Make no mistake, their distrust of the commercial radio industry is real. And so was their music. Making an argument that Smooth Jazz was in decline is like wearing an "Obama '08" t-shirt at a Republican primary with Smooth Jazz fans.
It won't be pleasant.
You can try to resurrect it on FM now and in some areas, you might even have a chance. But most importantly, just save what's left.
Because in a strange way, terrestrial radio actually NEEDS this format to compliment the Classic Rock, News/Talk, Sports and Oldies channel buttons on a Boomer's car radio.
And some people simply want a general, safe, all-purpose, non-threatening background music to play at work, in traffic. Or around the house.
Smooth Jazz was not my particular instant choice (I usually looked around to see what else was on before I tuned into KWJZ), But in the bigger picture, I've come to believe it actually had a bigger place than what was taken for granted.....