Yes, I would agree. Digital consoles are nice for multi-studio operations, since you don't have all that wiring betwixt and between studios. For a stand alone studio, price alone eliminates digital over analog.
But modern analog consoles, like the R-55E's I have, or even the old Auditronics 2500 series I still have in two studios, have very respectable noise and distortion specs, and, more importantly are repairable in the field.
Much is made of -90 db noise figures for digital consoles. Do the numbers, and the differences shrink: To avoid clipping, levels need to be set to keep voice peaks 12 to 15 db below maximum levels. Now your noise floor is only -75 db. Back in the old days, I could get -65 db noise figures off reel machines with low noise tape.
And what sources does the modern station have that would provide 90 db snr?
Computer sound cards? Open mikes? Satellite feeds?