You talk about how Andy will turn everything around, then talk about a "totally sydicated" station with no payroll, blah blah blah. First of all, Furman may be talented, but the effect of being on the #1 station helps anyone. Plenty of hosts who were once on "the big station" in town who were too lazy to move elsewhere have become nobodies and bounced further and further down the food chain in their original market. If you think 96.5 will be some huge success just by adding Furman, think again.
As to ratings/sales, agencies do not buy every station. Which ones don't they buy? The ones with no ratings. The reason WCKY sells overnights to preachers is because preachers have plenty of money to spend and feel that buying one station that reaches a huge part of the U.S. is sexier and more economical than buying a bunch of tiny ones. (of course, only radio geeks go looking for out-of-market stations to DX these days) It's not like anyone is clamoring to buy spots at 2:30am, so they'll do whatever they can to monetize the hours when no one in Cincinnati is listening (because they, unlike the preachers, only care about Cincinnati). Why doesn't everyone do it? For most, lack of saleability - buying overnights on WPFB is worthless; for some, incompetence or ego. As for paid programming at night on 96.5, don't count on it. Outside of some informercials or Roy Masters (already on 'CKY), few want to target just one city at an hour when few people are up let alone listening to radio. AM of FM, the rate would be pretty low.
And as for WCVG, I think you understand that I was implying, half tongue-in-cheek, that that's where this new talk station should have gone, rather than taking up FM bandwidth, not that WCVG is a paragon of excellence. For that, I was referring to the CC talk cluster, which seems plenty full, even with its hearty appetite.