TheBigA said:Getting back to the main topic of this thread, we live in a world of cyber-communities. Actual communities don't matter, because those who live there give more of their time and attention to the cyber-communities. So radio stations that spend lots of time addressing the needs of real communities, and disregard the action in the cyber-community, will be seen as out of touch.
It's going to be hard for me to make this argument.... for you and others have observed that I negotiate my way through the cyber-community with average or better results/skills/comfort. Someone in this conversation who shall go un-named at this point pointed me to a book named "Tribes" for which I am grateful. I have come to realize that I am a member of a particular tribe. There are some events in life that I do not wish to do by auto-pilot or other cyber-means.
I needed a new hot water heater. The old one was leaking. I went to a store with something of a nationwide footprint to purchase a water heater and arrange for them to install it. My neighbor had used them... and seemed happy. Oh, I can't take your order. (There was a phone bolted to the wall within the water heater display.) You must CALL the 800 number. As I explained to him "I don't buy food at McDonalds through the squawk box." he dialed the phone, and shouted at it as he worked his way through the voice-recognition menu tree. Had I been on the phone, I would have hung up and gone down the street looking for another vendor. After three days of unmitigated mental hell, I had a new hot water heater that is working quite well, and two weeks later I still don't know what I paid for the damn thing because the 800 number hasn't provided me paper work yet.
I understand that I at this point am distorting what you mean by cyber-community, but I must debate with you that there will always remain a significant amount of "actual community" in this old world. I don't know if I represent 1% of the population, 8% or maybe 60%..... but radio programming and management concepts that assume the whole of the population has to learn to live with programming based on the cyber-community model may not be the answer broadcasters should be seeking.
My next home purchase will be a new HVAC install. I will milk the cyber-community mechanics to understand the technical aspects of choosing a heating and A/C unit, features that I might find appealing, and brands that might be good choices. But I can assure you there will be no 800 phone number used in setting up that transaction!
Now... as a heavy-duty thinker in the world of broadcasting... cogitate for awhile on what that might mean in guessing what kind of radio I will be listening to Monday morning... and what I will NOT be listening to. And then try and guess the size of my tribe. ;D