The Fan might make some inroads on mid-days simply because Michael Irvin is unlistenable. For those who don't want Norm and BAD radio, maybe Newie and Sean are a workable option. If the Fan can't make up ground on mid-days, they should just wave the white flag now.
I will admit that Ben and Skin are slightly better with Tim Cowlishaw these days. Still, their sports coverage lacks the humor and folksy feel of GAC and the wheels-off appeal of The Hardline. I can't see B,S,& T winning afternoon drive. I would tune in if they had the morning shift simply because Gordon Keith is a total beating.
All in all, I still don't think there is room for three sports stations in this market. Since the Ticket is still king and since ESPN will fight to stay in the market, the Fan is simply doomed.