Re: The Planet
Obtuse1 said:
Ron_Mexico said:
The Planet and 14X proved to Buffalo radio execs that there was a market for Alternative radio in Buffalo.
and going further back, WUWU.
Allow me to play the benevolent contrarian here (it's such a stretch given some of my past posts.)
IF the aforementioned stations were proof that there was a market for Alternative radio in Buffalo, wouldn't you think at least ONE of them would be operating successfully, that is, reasonably profitable and in business today?
For the record, I believe there's a moderate hole for a professionally administered Adult Album Alternative station in Buffalo. The format, however, can be enigmatic, and therein lies the problem, especially since the AAA format is predicated on playing CURRENT or RECENT music. If
[email protected] had the proper direction, it might be that radio station today.
To be sure, in a graying and somewhat neanderthal market such as Buffalo; Boston, Led Zeppelin and The Doors are an easier sell than Norah Jones, Beck and the John Butler Trio. There are other issues as well. The presentation of most AAA stations lacks any genuine excitement or enthusiasm. 97 Rock exudes both. The Lake, on the other hand, is totally bland, and therein lies one of its major character flaws. It has little or no character.
The Lake sometimes approaches being AAA, yet so often takes the incorrect exit ramp and loses its direction. Because it leans so "classic" and of late, downright "oldies," it misses the "AAA" exit ramp and stay on the classic highway, Interstate 107.7.
The Lake does, however, have a more "adult," if not sometimes soporific approach (discounting the birds, crickets and trickling water sound effects.) 97 Rock is the epitome of localism, but can sound occasionally sophomoric. Still, of the two stations, 97 Rock has the more vital approach.
Any hope of The Lake playing more current music seems remote. Given that WHTT has moved away from "classics," both The Lake and 97 Rock seem all too eager to fill the void by playing Three Dog Night and James Brown. It's too bad, because there are a number of legitimate, commercially viable artists and groups that are selling CURRENT music to men and women 35-64 years of age. While these consumers may enjoy The Who, Jimi Hendrix and Foreigner, they are very interested in new music from classic artists and new music from new artists and groups.
Even with CanCon (which can be as interesting as it is disonant to some listeners), it's my opinion that 101.1 sounded best when it was leaning AAA as The River. Anyway, that's my view from this side of the river.
-9-