The “names” do not mean a whole lot to the typical music listener... Some truly great Nashville stations of the past (WMAK, WVOL, WKDA /KDF, WLAC, and WSIX etc.) may be recalled by some of us in the business, but programming content is king in PPM. This was really “brought home” to me last week. 96 Rock (WKLS) was successful for decades in Atlanta because it was the dial position and the music type. They had “evolved” from an AOR station (like the old 1970’s WKDA FM / KDF) to a classic rock with a slight AOR flavor. 97.1 came in with a “better” playlist, fewer commercials and took no PPM prisoners. (WKLS is now Project 9 6 1) Just last week I was in an office on a sales call and heard a radio playing in the copy room so I ask what station they were listening too and she said 96 Rock, just then the 97.1 sweeper played!
IMHO, If the listener can find your station’s signal on scan, they like your music (or talk show host) and you get preset you are in business. How many people will stay with your station or switch just because they like or dislike the voice sweeper or liner in between the songs? Play a bunch of crappy songs or put on a boring talk show host and see what happens. It is the good content (music, or talk show host) not “cute” nicknames or heritage that will win in PPM.