xmtrland said:
Would the metal water tank provide a good enough ground plane or should I install about 30 to 40 radials 50 feet long like we did for the first one.
You described installing the transmitter at ground level and using a short vertical radiator above the water tower so that the top of the short vertical is not higher than the 15 meter height allowed for TIS radiators. If you drive the base of the short vertical through a loading coil there, using a transmitter at earth level, and attach the braid of your coax transmission line to the water tower near the base of the short vertical, then the entire structure (water tower + short vertical) will radiate. In effect it will be an off-center-fed dipole.
Whether or not you can or should install buried ground radials depends on how well this composite antenna radiates. TIS rules limit transmitter power to 10 watts,
and the (accurately measured) groundwave field strength at 1.5 km to 2 millivolts/meter. If the efficiency of the antenna system is high, then the transmitter power would have to be reduced so that the field strength limit was met. OTOH, if you can't reach the field strength limit with 10 watts of transmitter power you can't increase the power above 10 watts.
Probably the water tower structure itself is connected to the physical earth, but that wouldn't supply a good r-f ground. A good r-f ground for a vertical monopole requires radial wires extending in all directions from the base of the radiating structure, so that the displacement currents produced by radiation from the antenna can be collected and returned to the tx/antenna system with minimum loss. That loss is in series with the antenna current, and can have a large affect on radiation efficiency.
But a quick look with NEC for the configuration described shows fairly good radiator gain on 1650 kHz. Even if the r-f ground resistance was 100 ohms, it may take just a few watts for this system to produce the maximum legal field for TIS stations.
There is no clear answer here, but hopefully this information will be useful.
//