I never paid too much attention to the translator discussions on these boards. They usually were on the technical side of things and too “over my head” to be honest. Well, I’m seeing things in a different light. Through translators, especially ones that result in a half-way decent signal, I believe it can fill programming holes and get more people listening who may not otherwise.
A number of you would like to see a different kind of urban or rhythmic format come to Jacksonville. You can put me in that camp as well. Obviously I would not want that at The Dove’s expense. Still, I believe Cox has an opportunity to shake up the market and enhance their position.
A while back, I talked of how the signal should help determine the format. The last time, to my knowledge, a rhythmic format was tried on a signal that at least for technical reasons made sense was on 100.7. Well, it didn’t work out. Unfortunately, a brand was chosen that at the time did not have a track record. I don’t believe there were any syndicated programs or even a live and local person with whom the urban core recognized as one of their own. There was no real budget that could have made a difference and it went away. If Cox brings an urban or rhythmic AC or any hybrid to market, it probably will have to be more unique to what exists. Cox has a history of doing urban type formats very well.
Speaking of unique, Jacksonville is not alone in that there is a lot of overlap in music. I can understand how Jacksonville radio got to the state that it is in, but I believe the market is ripe for change.
The other morning I was at a convenience store. “Sweet Home Alabama” was playing in the background. What surprised me was I heard the song on Rock 104.5. Then I recall the PD mentioning how the music was tweaked and how their listeners wanted to hear those occasional classics. I’m not knocking the decision. Still, don't you find it amazing that for a market that acts like they are so adverse to bringing and keeping a retro top 40 to market because the music is old feature so much old music all over the dial?
But I figure there are at least 4 stations across 4 different formats featuring this 39 year old song. There are dozens of other examples for this as well. It’s probably a downside to music testing. Opinions really count for those 35-45. We shouldn’t be surprised at the songs these listeners favor and so we get lots of sameness. It may achieve targets but it alienates many listeners as well and I still believe that is not healthy for radio. Being inclusive especially in a diverse community makes sense or it should.
Now translators come along. Perhaps mistakes of the past can be corrected. I’m not expecting the majority of posters to this board to embrace The Dove. Many of you are rock-oriented and that’s perfectly OK. But I think you would have to agree, not all listeners share the same appreciation for certain genres of music. There are probably enough “younglees” out there who can support a new urban format to make it viable. I know I represent many listeners as well.
As far as demographics go, remember stats can be anything you want them to be. The Jax market is huge and musical taste changes depending on where you are. As a side note, WFEZ beats the classic hits format in 25-54 so we should not make assumptions. There is no doubt, formats such as The Dove attract older demos. But there is also a mass-appeal quality as well. When done right, there is viability and at least 1 station in the market that features something different. It's a win/win folks. There was a time, Jax had a Soft AC, a Rhythmic AC and an Oldies Station. Maybe it’s time the signal determines the format. With the Dove, Cox has filled about 1.5 in programming holes. If another urban comes to town as well, I would say radio in Jacksonville would be giving listeners a lot more choices and it's time is now.