I'm not familiar with the Bishopville current economic climate versus the past.
Your comments are 100% correct. I love that you offer such great detail. It should be very valuable to the person looking to get their own station. Ownership was never easy even where there were fewer slices in the advertising pie. It's not easy today. You just have to be creative and learn how to do more with less, sometimes much less. Labor of love enters the picture as the extra work gives you just enough income but not cover the extra work it involved.
Not only do the chain stores not buy radio, they tend to make it harder for the mom and pop business that competes to stay afloat. Dollar General or Family Dollar can have this impact. Small town businesses are close to the edge anyway. They have a limited customer base, buy in smaller volume and have a lot less 'wiggle room' that a business in a larger community. When that local buys at the big chain store in the next town or goes online to buy, the little guy hurts a little more. In short, that gap between profit and loss is much thinner today than it ever was.
There's much more competition for the ad dollar as well. There are not just all those new stations that popped up on the dial over the past few decades but all those upgrades to stations made, such as going from a 6kw to say a 50kw to try to serve a more regional area. Chances are the cable company has a sales rep coming through town here and there to sell clients. You have the local paper out selling. You have 'shoppers' that you see at store entrances with their 'free, take one' sign and the ones that arrive in the mailbox. And then there is the online presence. Some merchants are cutting back on advertising to use Facebook and frequents posts there to market themselves. Because they might get a few comments they think, wow, instant results.
All of this means the local small town station has a rough go of it. And that newspaper, I know a lady that owned a small town paper. About 2004 or so, she was selling about $85,000 in advertising a year in her little town (a mere $25 million in retail sales). Ten years later her state recognized award winning paper was down to $35,000 in advertising sold for the year. She went a year not taking a salary and trying to turn the tide. She shut down. Also, the subscription price, thanks to higher printing costs, usually doesn't cover the printing and postage (for this publisher it cost 60 cents an issue for printing and postage versus 50 cents retail price for the paper, a weekly 8 pager). Radio isn't the only media facing the tough road.
For this publisher, it wasn't the poor job she was doing, it was the competition from online (including Facebook) and the 'shoppers' that touted multi-county coverage and reader numbers of maybe 25 times her actual readership that ate at her slice of the advertising pie.
I have looked seriously at some stations I wanted to try to buy. I have seen a trend. At one point a radio station might get as much as $5 per $1,000 in retail sales in the small town. That's when you are running like a well oiled machine. Today that well oiled machine can barely do $2.25 to $2.50. Depending on the station and the town, about 50 cents per $1,000 in retail sales might be realistic. That would mean a town like Bishopville might only bill about $50,000 a year under the worst case scenario but $225,000 to $250,000 at the very most if everything was perfect. The average would be about $10,000 to $12,000 a month for a place like Bishopville. Looking at Bishopville, the fact WAGS is an AM daytimer on a fairly crowded radio landscape, I suspect it is more like $50,000. From what I gather, the average seems to be about $1.33 based on the small town stations I have looked at.
I understand the station is still for sale. Yes, it includes the studio/office and tower in the backyard. I have no knowledge of the equipment or ground system. At least the asking price will make you want to take a look. The seller isn't like most. He isn't looking for that buyer to be his winning lottery ticket. I've seen just a CP have a bigger asking price.