aaronread said:
Worth mentioning is that for many, many years, the college radio stations sounded a lot like what you hear on WFNX now. Well, okay, obviously they're as "polished" or "commercial", but the style of rock was not dissimilar. It was stations like WBCN and WFNX moving more into the "alt-rock" category and away from AOR that "drove" the college stations to being more and more "underground rock", in order to maintain that elitist stance of "we play what the commercial stations won't".
That was what
eventually happened, but not what originally happened. DJ's like Oedipus, Tom Lane and others pioneered punk rock in this area in the mid-70s on WMBR when WBCN was still playing mainstream AOR. WBCN was still playing exclusively the ilk of what is now classic rock (The Eagles, Lynyrd Skynyrd, Pink Floyd, Led Zep, etc...) when those DJ's on WMBR began playing the Sex Pistols, Patti Smith, the Buzzcocks, the Dead Kennedys, etc... and WFNX was still WLYN-FM, a local-service AC station. It wasn't even "Y-102" (WLYN-FM's pre-WFNX New Wave format) yet.
WBCN started tuning into (the more mainstream end of) New Wave and punk a year or two after WMBR (and WZBC shortly thereafter) pioneered it,
then (the new rock shows on) WMBR, WZBC and other college stations became increasingly obscure to maintain their esoteric position.
aaronread said:
Problem is, instead of working to find acts that might be just on the verge of going big and beating the commercial stations to it...most (not all, but most) college stations instead focused on finding bands that commercial would never play, which rapidly because "music that 99% of all listeners will shut off the radio if we play it". Much easier to just define yourself as what you're not than to try and define what you are. Of course, in doing so you give listeners no reason to ever listen to you in the first place, but it's easier.
That's one of the things I find frustrating about a lot of college radio. There is so much
good music that commercial radio is not playing that college stations could play, and still be unique in playing it on the dial, without snidely resorting to purposely turning off listeners for the sake of elitism. And, to be fair, some college shows/DJ's do just that and do a fine job, but the attitude of the elitist anti-listener DJ's (except for a very small like-minded clique of their own peers) still bugs me.
aaronread said:
After all, are there not enough excellent alt-rock bands that aren't getting airplay on WBCN or WFNX? I find that exceedingly hard to believe, given their "narrow" playlists. I wouldn't exactly say that WZBC or WMBR could wipe the floor with WBCN or WFNX if they wanted to. But I would say that WFNX, at least, would be sweating quite a bit if either WZBC or WMBR actually geared up to go toe-to-toe with them.
That won't happen. Even if they decided that they wanted to (which they don't), I don't think either college station is set up tightly enough internally management-wise to pull it off logistically.
timpani said:
I completely agree. Also WERS. They are sounding stellar these days. Not as "punked up" as ZBC or MBR, but playing excellent music that commercial radio won't touch.
WERS is doing something different - it's what I call a form of "eclectic AAA", and as a station run by a professional communications school that actively
wants their station to be a ratings and fundraising success, I think it was a very smart idea for them going forward. As the currently college-age and young adult iPod generation grows up, I think the type of format that WERS is doing will resonate well. Look for more non-comms (or perhaps even comms) elsewhere adopting similar formats eventually.