Steve,
LOL. I was amazed at this coincidence! WFAT was an AM pirate with a call-in show that I could just make out thru the crashing static listening from Seaford. It WAS me who called in. Back in 1978-79 the phone company had these loop lines where you called on number, the other party called it's matching phone number and the two were connected together. WFAT would give one out hoping not to be traced whe they would call it's matching number. Another night during a fierce snowstorm these guys called themselves "Icy Radio" WICE. You made me dig out my SWL logbook from 1978 and there it is! WFAT, I even have a QSL from that pirate. But that's not the coincidence, read on!
All heard in Seaford from just north of Sunrise Hwy:
1/12/78 WJVR pirate 1620am call-in show
1/16/78 WGOR pirate 1620am signing off
1/21/78 WICE pirate 1625am taking calls during snowstorm
1/21/78 WGOR pirate 1625am Simon and Garfunkle music
1/21/78 WPOT pirate 1620am call in show
1/23/78 WGOR pirate 1628am call in show
2/07/78 WFSR pirate 1628am call in show
5/30/78 WFAT pirate 1620am call in show with announcers Gary and Hal, same announcer as WGOR
1/05/79 WFAT pirate 1620am call in show
In 1980 I'm just a kid, on the air at WXLO. One night I took one of a million requests on the phone and some voices just stand out. One particular caller asks me to play something. I asked him if he was the WFAT guy, I recognized his voice and it BLEW him away.

There was no connection between us (that I know of). I just happened to be listening to his short pirate broadcast the year before, and now the same fella was calling into WXLO for a request.

I'm so glad you remembered WFAT. Were you connected somehow? Who was the announcer? I think the statute of limitations is up on that one. I'd love to know.