LBB's Fantasy Market
This is pure fantasy ... but if I could convince folks to "play with their properties", this would be my lay of the land in 2007:
SANDUSKY
92.5: MOVIN seems to be on an upswing. RIDE IT!
KIXI, KWJZ, KRWM: Roll with it, baby!
1150: All traffic during AM-end of PM drive, including weekends. Automate so easy to loop segments only when the information changes. Specialty (pay-for-play) or satellite programming evenings; but use evening stopset breaks for quick traffic updates to handle things like SeaCenter events, etc. and protect the image of full time traffic.
FISHER
101.5: Consider branding KOMO-FM: Mix of personality/music and full service, target those who want KOMO-info but not full strength info. Airstaff they have is perfect to make this work -- only real change is less emphasis on wall-to-wall music. Already have the investment in newsroom & resources, and an FM mid-range would balance their "local information" positioning of AM-TV-FM.
KOMO/KVI: Pair these up so they are real sister stations. Make it so people know the two are related. KOMO currently has mariners which to me messes up "we're information when you need it" credibility; so if people are taught to think of the pair you can pick up news/traffic on 570 when Mariners commitment is underway. Ideally move Mariners to 570; but KOMO has better signal. I'd seriously consider backing off the right-wing thing and make KVI an "issues" station where each host attracts a certain TYPE of following --- positioning is "in-depth analysis of what we introduce of KOMO".
CBS
KPTK: KMPS, KZOK: Stay the course (some would argue KPTK's strength, but let's see what happens in November and what national climate is like at that point)
96.5: The talk about making this a softer AC makes some sense .... would be good addition to the format mix at CBS; and doesn't cannibalize anything they already have
KBKS: Haven't listened so not sure of the degree to which they are struggling; but I have to assume there is SOME room for a good CHR/Contemporary station that picks up teens and is "palatable" for parents. Most old dweebs my age can't stomach even sampling KUBE ... so get something Mom/kids agree on in the SUV. My perception of KISS was they weren't that far away from this; but stopped trying to keep adults happy.
CLEAR CHANNEL
850/950, KFNK, KNBQ: Have to assume these are doing well in their niches. Not much you can do with the "regional" signal holdbacks of the FM's ... so the way they operate those is economical and keeps a decent hole filled in each case.
KUBE: Yeah, I'm nostalgic for the days when it was a serious #1 priority on my preset; but hard to argue with its success ... so hang in there, man!
KJR-FM: This one's an emotional choice ... but I would LOVE to see it take up the "gold" mantle and restore its heritage presentation. Squash KBSG at their own game by taking up complete but newer library and get a huge cume. With large library, TSL would probably improve too. But make it energetic, personality, foreground and FUN ... not just a jukebox. When you're hearing the same library over time the thing that makes it unique is what happens WITH the music; otherwise off-air media makes sense to just have "the library" in your car.
ENTERCOM
KIRO: Figure out what you want to be and go for it. Enough heritage material to bring it back to "glory" status if you stop tweaking the dials and oiling the machine every 15 minutes. Give the market a chance to remember what originally worked at KIRO ... CONSISTENCY and CREDIBILITY! If they really want Mariners back they will end up with exact same issue KOMO faces .. are you the flagship sports station or are you news leader? Can't be both and have people count on you for breaking news/traffic.
770: If KVI could do the "issues" positioning, then this would leave hard-core right talk open for one station to wrap itself around.
WOLF, KISW, KMTT: Like 'em but need to decide if music or a yak-yak-yak format. Each has potential of "owning" their respective niche (assuming WOLF continues to be "young" targeted country and KMPS assumes to be "older" target).
107.7: Still like the concept of going after somethin very unique ... like the Buble kind of AC (not pop ... but mix of old and new "standards"). Don't trust Entercom to program this as a good FM news station, and simply simulcasting KIRO doesn't make sense until you FIX KIRO's erosion first.
KBSG: Since my emotional vote for "gold" went to KJR (because it earned that place in our history first), I'd look at this to round out adult music mix. At some point I think the Entercom holdings prove that you CAN have too many stations in a market and that instead of being effective, you eventually can't find ways not to screw yourself by stealing from your own sisters. If they do classic rock of some kind ... it steps on KISW. If they do talk, it steps on KIRO/770. Can't go country; If 107.7 takes a unique AC approach, can't go mainstream, ecletic taken by KMTT ... so perhaps clearest path is an adult Contemporary station ... something that retools Hot-AC (esp. if KPLZ adopts the KOMO-FM thing) and make it music-intensive adult foreground.
So...who's first to flip??!!!