Simple. Most of the younger programmers coming up in the business are either
A) Afraid to take chances, worried that they'll lose their job in the process. Can't entirely blame them with all the changes going around, now can we?
B) They've been brainwashed to believe that only CHRs in the Top 20 markets are allowed to break new records, and that the rest of them should follow those playlists like a bunch of sheep.
101.1 WIXX Green Bay is a great example of how CHRs can sound unique for their markets and make it work. Don't get me wrong, I love the fact that Kiss 95.9 is also in town as they do a great job of playing all the big national hits, but WIXX has a certain distinct Green Bay and even Midwestern feel to it.
Z-100 New York, both 97.1 Amp Radio and 102.7 KIIS-FM do a great job of playing the right music for their markets. They understand which records they can jump early on, and which records they should be more cautious about. Their PDs rely both on research and on gut instinct, and that's the way it should be. The same is true for a number of other CC-owned CHRs like 106.1 Kiss FM Dallas, Channel 93-3 San Diego, or 93.3 FLZ Tampa.
Ever looked at the ratings for stations like KJ 103 Oklahoma City? They're a true blue all-hit music station and their ratings are always very high. The guys there know how often to rotate the music, and have a can do attitude as far as mixing up a diverse set of music that's still within the confines of Top 40 radio. Rival Wild 104.9 may still be labelled by some in the industry as a Rhythmic, but it's really good at jumping early on Rhythmic hits as well as embracing the big Pop and even Pop/Rock hits pretty quickly. Oklahoma's other big market, Tulsa, is similar in nature with both 106.9 K-Hits and 92.1 The Beat sounding anything but stale. And we're talking about Oklahoma here, one of the more conservative states in the country.
Charlotte's Kiss 95.1 and 96.1 The Beat are great to point out, Q-92 Canton, 93.7 STW Wilmington, 103.7 Kiss FM Milwaukee, 93.7 KRQ Tucson, 98.5 KRZ Wilkes Barre, 104.5 SNX Grand Rapids, 96.5 The Mountain Chattanooga are all among my favorite stations.
B-93.7 Greenville currently has Seether's "Careless Whisper" as it's most played song, a record which may be a stiff nationally, but performing well at this highly rated CHR (as well as several other ones)