I think the market needs both a real all-sports station (all automation on 980 AM ain't cuttin' it) AND a classic country station, so the demise of WGOC is disapointing.
I was told the switch was predicated in large part because the audience for classic country had gotten so old, it was no longer profitable to keep the format on its frequency.
Combine that with what happened with Tom Taylor, who lasted for about a week as a sports talk show host, then moved to become a morning host on WGOC, then went to the Hills on one of their AM outlets. WGOC was still able to get respectible ratings on 1320 (1.0 or so), but when Taylor left, that essentially did it for the station.
The other thing is WXSM. While sports radio stations rarely get huge ratings, they tend to do well sales-wise because they can deliver a male demographic. Unfortunately, the people at Citadel don't seem to understand selling a sports radio station. They've had a number of out and out BAD sales ideas- such as the Crabtree Buick ads sung to "Take Me Out to the Ballgame," or "Ladies Days Wednesdays"- which would be akin to WGOC having a "Teenager Tuesday."
Now, I don't know. WXSM might be booking tons of money. But the programming isn't what it could be. Examples-
A- They insist on having a local morning show instead of airing "Mike and Mike" and pre-emptiing Colin Cowherd, who simply doesn't fit in with the market, for a local show.
B- The local morning show has already gone through three different hosts in just two years on the air- Taylor, Don Helman, and Joe Avento.
C- When a host needs a day off, they don't call for a pinch-hitter. They instead have Bill Meade or Bobby Rader pull double duty.
D- The hosts are largely apologists for the subjects they cover- Vols, ETSU, high schools, etc. When it became apparent that Phil Fulmer had to go last year, WXSM was still defending him as if it was 1998.
E- There's too much emphasis on national topics and not enough on local ones. ESPN radio already covers the national stuff and does it better than a station based in Johnson City ever could. Yet where is the coverage of local sports issues? Hot button topics with journalistic responsibility include the Science Hill stadium issue, if high school football season begins too early in light of the tragedy with Sullivan South, or reviving football at ETSU. Yet these topics are avoided, while we hear over and over how Bud Selig is a poor commissioner and college football needs a playoff.
Again, the market needs a sports station and classic country. My suggestion is to kill the woefully underperforming WKOS, move WXSM there, and bring back classic country on 640.
Plan B would be to hire some real sales people that understand sports radio and its demographics and don't worry about selling to beer, gentleman's clubs, and touts, and for another station to change to a country format but inerject classic tunes into the rotation to take on WXBQ, which prides itself on finding the next big acts out of Nashville and less with days of yore.