How often do you see Sports talkers that have good numbers without play by play?
I’d like to think play by play adds a degree of “legitimacy” to a Sports station. The station becomes associated with the team and fans build a relationship with the station based on that partnership. Here in Cleveland, our FM sports talker started without local play by play for IIRC three years and had generally weak ratings during that time. Then, they gained a share of the Browns play by play and they’ve been a strong ratings player ever since. Take a look at San Diego, where The Fan is a top five station 6+ (and probably first in men 25-54) and the iHeart sports talker is at the bottom of the ratings.
Compelling hosts are important for any talk format, but play by play is the ingredient that “brings the dish together”.
Keep in mind that sports talk is an expensive format, so if you’re gonna run it, you’ve gotta give it the best opportunity to succeed, not try something different and hope