oldies76 said:
I believe the last time I heard a Barbra Streisand song ("Woman In Love", "The Way We Were") on KRTH was during that famous special way back in 1985. ;D
There is one very important thing that has not been adequately mentioned in the discussion of which old pop hits should be played on an oldies station or a classic hits station.
And that "thing" is the age span of the Top 40 / CHR listener.
In the 50's and 60's, in many if not most major markets, if your preferences were not country or r&b, you could either listen to Top 40 or you could listen to MOR. And looking at the Top 40 stations, we see that they were not just teen stations... they were dominant in 18-49. So many of the listeners were in their 30's and even 40's then!
Of course, those listeners are generally no longer with us. But the point is that the likes of those listeners were the major reasons why we had hits by Dominico Modugno, Perry Como, Dean Martin, Wayne Newton... and later, Barbra Streisand, the Carpenters and other traditional-leaning artists and songs.
Just look at the demos of the Tom Jones TV show... his popularity was driven by 25-44 women. Englebert, Barry Manilow and others were also significantly propelled by more mature demos.
So, naturally, many of the people who liked those songs tend to be in their 70s or 80s today. And the age groups that stations seek contains very few fans of that kind of music. Not only does this explain why those songs are not played, it also explains why a significant percentage of charting songs from past eras of pop / Top 40 / CHR are just unplayable today.