"If you wanted to draw such a cartoon about today's corporate radio industry...how about a drawing of some dumb guy(with "corporate radio" written on his lapel) holding a large gun toward his foot and ready to pull the trigger...no caption needed"
Picturing him with the gun barrel in his mouth is more like it these days.
When you take the value-added of live, local, entertaining personalities out of the radio mix, you reduce radio to a jukebox with commercials. You remove the last incentive to listen, and encourage people to go to their iPods, cassette decks and CD decks, where there's never a commercial, and you know you'll like every song played because you bought or downloaded them all.
Stupid. Radio needs to hold on to every edge it can, in a world where people have more alternatives than ever. Sure, it's user-friendly like no other medium, which is why it's probably still alive at all. But when people will go out of their way to choose other paths to audio entertainment, you have to figure you're doing something wrong with what you're programming--and taking the live local entertainment and information content away is the principal change station operators have made during the last 15 years. So that move to cut costs by cutting quality must be the thing that drives listeners away, and it's the thing that radio managers need to address first.
There's an example right here in New York State, of how going BACK to live personality radio can pay dividends. WCBS-FM in New York went to a jockless Jack format in 2005 and fell out of the top 10 all the way to the very bottom of the heap among full market signals within months. Its revenue fell by more than half. Two years later, CBS radio division boss Dan Mason brought back the personalities and live information content...the ratings soared to the point that they're now consistently in the top 5 in 12+ and 25-54 numbers in market #1...and even in a down economy, most of the lost revenue and profit has also come back. It's now the leading station in the CBS cluster in America's top market. That SHOULD be a lesson to everyone in the business.
Let's see who's paying attention....