Xtalker said
Truth is the actual advertiser has little input into the target audience. It is left up to the ad execs - whether in house or at the agency. That's why ad agencies hate it when stations go directly to the client. If a 55+ station has a solid sales force (that knows about real selling - not numbers selling) a client can be convinced to buy the station. Agencies will buck it every time! That 30 year old buyer has much more to say about it than you give them credit for!
This is not true. The advertiser generally has considerable input, geneally coming to the agency with complete demos on who the product or sevrvice was desigend for, which will be the buying demos for the campaigh. Clients like Proctor & Gamble will audit ad buys to make sure agencies do not buy stations that do not reach the product demo.
Every product is designed for a specific narrow or broad demo. Many are designed for lifestyle groups, or specific ethnic groups, too. A client goes to an agency with the product already ready, and knowing with the client's own research, who it appeals to... if a new product, who it was tested against.
In most cases (like the first 6 months in LA) there are NO buys for 55+. This means the client mandated other demos in all the agency buys that have come through. The agency can not change the design of the product and the client demo deemands.
Xtalker said
Whether reality or not, the 55+ formats suffer because the big money does not want the demo.
The advertisers, in most cased, did not design th eproduct for 55+, and do not want to spend the amount of money it takes to sell older demos... ther eis a low return on investment as it takes more ads to sell older consumers. And 55+ products advertise in direct mail, specialized magazines and cable, not radio. It's the way it is.
Xtalker said
You are right about the talk format - but listen to the average talk station and you don't find a lot of the mainstream advertisers - particularly at the local level.
What was maikjnstream yesterday is not today. 20 years ago,a mortgage cmpanies did not advertise much, now they are a mainstay of talk formats. It is just a changing economy that is more and more sevrice based.
Xtalker said
By the way, those car dealers that yell at you on talk stations could be much better served by a more conversational commercial. Why don't they understand the yelling might work on younger demo formats, but is much less effective on more adult formats?
They measure how many ups they get each day, and ask each up where they heard about the dealer. The loud ads work, so they keep doing them. The soft ones don't.
[/quote]