Stupidity on Citadel's part. Somehow they think the "everything that rocks" format that works in smaller markets, will work in DC. Obviously, it hasn't.
If I were Citadel I would make 105.9 WMAL-FM. However, I would keep most of the syndicated hosts on the AM side. I would do an AM and PM evening news/traffic/weather block focusing on LOCAL stories. Headlines at :00 and :30, with in-depth local stories and interviews in between. Middays would have to be a general, locally originated talk show. Perhaps the current morning show on 105.9 could be retooled to a talk format only?
The WMAL newscasts are contracted out, correct? Interesting to note sometimes you get more local information in that less than five minute newscast on WMAL than you get out of an entire half hour on WTOP. Trim the ads, the stupid banter between the anchors and everyone, the endless traffic tags, the 30 second long top of the hour ID, and every fluff story mandated by a musical introduction - and you have very little news on WTOP.
WTOP's ratings and billing are there because nobody has had the guns to topple them. Their product is awful compared to WCBS, WINS, etc. They win by default, because it is the only local news on the radio.