Well, good if he's playing some snippets of airchecks.
I heard it from a 5 CD set recorded from his first tribute, and both myself, and some other former WING people all agreed that was pretty weak. Perhaps between now and then, there's been some more to add...
WING was, in its' heyday, like WSAI, WCOL and others of the era were, very unique stations keyed in to their own locales. WING was, as I remember listening to it as a young boy, an "adult" Top 40 station during the day that got more frenetic after 3 pm. It had uptempo jocks, but the presentation was more adult during the day. At one point in its' history, it was one of the highest-billing Top 40's in the U.S. It was legendary for its' market and its' time.
So excuse some of us if we're particular about "tributes". We're very proud of our associations with that station, proud to have played some role in its' "legend". For me, though I came at almost the end, despite the fairly low pay for the time, it was a "dream job". I had finally "made it" to the station I idolized as a kid. To hear my voice coming back through the headphones saying those call letters, hearing the reverb on the air chain and the supurb AM stereo sound coming though the monitors in the control room, even at 3 in the morning, made me feel like I had arrived. We all tried to be keepers of the flame.
I was proudest of the fact that I was Kirkie's "accepted" fill-in while I was there. I still treasure an aircheck I have on the computer here filling in for Steve on the morning after the San Francisco earthquake. Listening back to it today, I could critique it to death, but love some of the bits we collaborated on. (Jim Blommel, our production guy at the time, did a great Marge Schott impersonation!)
So, sorry if some of us are particular. I hope you can appreciate the emotion by which a lot of the people who worked there still carry for it...some of us still want to protect it, even if those days are long gone.