Doodical said:
Hey Kevin,
Stop preaching and drinking the kool-aid of homogenized country radio. Rating don’t make a station great, it’s all Dayton has to listen too. You can’t compare Kiss Country because it didn’t have the power or reach of k99. You quote numbers and that’s all good and well, but it’s all Dayton gets. Come to Fort Worth and I’ll show you some country station's that kicks boots! Real personalities, new and old country (70’s, 80’s and modern mixed together). But then again Fort Worth is not Dayton!
You say the dj’s are now up-tempo, funny how you say “Now”, as I come to town about 1 weekend a month I have heard no change to k99. You won in the rating game, that must have been tough against stations like Kiss Country and the Rebel, but what did you really win? The station is an elevator country music station at best.
Your so called radio programming genius are not all that genius. When you are the only game in town you win by default, it doesn’t take a radio expert to figure this out! Country fans are loyal to their music and artist, not their station. Enjoy your success and country brand of radio, but don’t preach what great radio k99 is until you have beaten real competition, which you have never had in Dayton. I understand you are proud to work there and I think thats great. Congratulations on your ratings. Just my UN programming opinion, I don’t claim to be a radio genius, but I do know good radio when I hear it…remember, I’m a listener!
Dood...or whoever you are:
I have beaten real competition...in Columbus...market 35. 3 radio stations came after us. I did middays then...#1 25-54 for 2 straight years in the country format. Also there, we went head to head with a much better financed competitor in a different format, which we beat 13 out of 13 rating books.
After that, I went off and programmed 2 other stations. The first was financially successful even though being an out of town rimshot restricted the ratings we could realistically achieve. The second, I took from #6 to #1 in 6 months.
I have never claimed to be God's gift to programming. Anyone who knows me knows that. But I've learned from some of the best in the business about radio battles, and know what makes good radio...and here it is in a nutshell: what the listeners want the station to do.
That's why you do audience and perceptual research. That's what K-99 does...and that's why it's successful.
About the only accurate thing you posted was that Dallas and Dayton are 2 different animals. They are. There are artists who play in Texas, you can't play in Dayton. Or Columbus. And programming Texas-style in Dayton...fails.
Listening on one stray weekend day doesn't even give you a snapshot of a station.
You say K-99 is "elevator country". Yet, I'm doing the same delivery I did in Columbus, with only one difference: I've been told to sound even more uptempo. Our afternoon guy, Shane Collins, is a young guy who sounds like he could fit on any station. The morning show has been seriously freshened with the combined talents of Nancy Wilson and Frey Guy. In a nutshell, any country fan from 18-54 can listen and enjoy the station.
Since the demise of Kiss Country, we have ventured out to give Clark County a station that they can consider "home". We're up there every weekday in the van. We've built a studio in News-Sun building and will soon be able to...and will whenever it makes sense to...broadcast from that studio. We have an address in Springfield now. We're as local there, as we are in Dayton, especially considering that our tower throws a city grade signal over just about that whole area.
In today's PPM world, the listeners seem to be telling radio one thing: entertain me, but shut up and play the hits. And "the leader" can be taken down with better structured, streamlined programming. The problem with guys like you is that you really think taking radio back to 1970 will win. It's a far different world and radio has to reflect that.
And, the only game in town can be beaten (or seriously brought down to size)...if the only game in town is as bad as you suggest K is. But, that's simply not the case.
Country fans are loyal to K-99.1 because we give them what they want. Lots of music, jocks who reflect their music and their world. And, we respect the music and respect the listeners. That's how you get their loyalty.
Who knows what competition could come down the pike? You can't say and neither can I. But, I can say Cox has won a lot of head to head battles in other markets...